Background of the Case
The Rajasthan High Court was dealing with a criminal revision petition filed by Vijendra Singh, a police officer facing trial in a corruption case before a Special Court in Sri Ganganagar.
The accused sought production of the complainant's Call Detail Records (CDRs) and mobile tower-location data to support his defence that the complainant was not present at the place and time mentioned in the FIR.
The trial court rejected the application on the grounds that the accused had not specified the statutory provision under which such relief could be granted and that the case was still at the stage of consideration of charges.
High Court's Observations
Justice Farjand Ali observed that the right to a fair trial includes a meaningful opportunity for an accused to secure and preserve evidence that may support the defence.
The Court noted that electronic records such as call details and tower-location data are maintained by telecom service providers and may be automatically deleted after a prescribed retention period. Waiting until the defence evidence stage could therefore result in the permanent loss of potentially important material.
It emphasised that preservation of evidence at an early stage does not amount to prematurely accepting defence evidence or deciding its admissibility. The purpose is to ensure that relevant material remains available for consideration at the appropriate stage of the proceedings.
The Court observed:
"The accused cannot be deprived of a fair and reasonable opportunity to place relevant material in support of his defence merely because the trial has progressed to a particular stage."
The Court also followed the principle laid down in Chotha Ram v. State of Rajasthan, recognising that preservation of electronic evidence is distinct from formally leading defence evidence during trial.
Final Decision
The High Court allowed the criminal revision petition and directed the trial court to take steps to obtain the requested call records and tower-location details from the concerned authorities, if the information was still available.
The Court clarified that the material produced could be placed on record and relied upon by either party during the trial. Its preservation would not amount to any prior determination of its admissibility or evidentiary value.
Case Details
Case Name: Vijendra Singh v. State of Rajasthan
Court: Rajasthan High Court
Citation: 2026 LiveLaw (Raj) 495
Case Number: S.B. Criminal Revision Petition No. 1026/2023
Coram: Justice Farjand Ali






