Private Insurance Companies Amenable To Writ Jurisdiction
The Delhi High Court has held that private insurance companies performing functions of a public character can be subjected to judicial review under Article 226 of the Constitution, even if they do not qualify as 'State' under Article 12.
Justice Jasmeet Singh observed that insurance companies perform functions similar to those of the State by providing financial protection to the public and acting as a social safety net. Their private corporate status does not automatically place their actions beyond the jurisdiction of constitutional courts.
The Court observed:
"Insurance companies deal with matters of a public nature and perform functions akin to those of the State."
Background Of The Case
The Court was hearing a writ petition filed by Smt. Sushma Tyagi, whose husband and his brother had jointly purchased a residential property in Greater Noida by obtaining a home loan of ₹50 lakh.
They had also obtained a Home Credit Assure insurance policy from HDFC Ergo General Insurance Company to protect the loan.
After her husband died due to cardiac arrest on April 20, 2021, the petitioner submitted an insurance claim. However, HDFC Ergo rejected the claim, contending that cardiac arrest was not covered under the specified critical illnesses.
Her subsequent complaint before the Insurance Ombudsman was also dismissed.
Insurance Company's Objection Rejected
HDFC Ergo argued that the writ petition was not maintainable because it was a private company and did not fall within the definition of 'State' under Article 12.
Rejecting this contention, the High Court relied upon the Supreme Court's decisions in Andi Mukta Sadguru v. V.R. Rudani and Ajay Vijh v. Indian Banks Association.
The Court explained that the scope of Article 226 is wider than Article 12 and extends to private bodies performing public duties.
It further clarified that writ jurisdiction is not automatically available in every contractual dispute. However, the nature of the functions performed, the legal issues involved and the existence of disputed questions of fact must be examined in each case.
Since the present dispute primarily involved interpretation of the insurance policy and raised issues concerning natural justice, the Court held that the petition was maintainable.
Cardiac Arrest Covered Under Insurance Policy
On the merits, the Court examined whether cardiac arrest could fall within the policy's definition of 'Myocardial Infarction'.
It observed that the insurer's own explanation established a connection between the two conditions and that both could be described as a heart attack in common parlance.
Applying the principle of contra proferentem, the Court held that ambiguity in an insurance policy must be interpreted against the insurer who drafted it.
Consequently, cardiac arrest was held to fall within the policy coverage.
Insurance Ombudsman's Order Also Set Aside
The Court further found that the Insurance Ombudsman had failed to properly adjudicate the petitioner's complaint after she declined to sign a mediation form.
It held that the Ombudsman was required to proceed with adjudication rather than dismiss the complaint, thereby violating the principles of natural justice.
Final Decision
Allowing the writ petition, the High Court quashed both the insurance company's repudiation letter and the Insurance Ombudsman's award.
HDFC Ergo was directed to pay ₹27,97,445, representing 50% of the insured amount, along with 9% annual interest from the date of rejection of the claim until payment.
The insurer was also directed to reimburse ₹5,08,176 towards the corresponding home loan interest paid by the petitioner, along with subsequent interest attributable to that portion until actual payment.
Case Details
Case Name: Smt. Sushma Tyagi v. M/s HDFC Ergo General Insurance Company Limited & Ors.
Court: Delhi High Court
Date of Decision: 18 November 2026
Case Number: W.P. (C) 168/2024
Coram: Justice Jasmeet Singh






