Unauthorized Recording of Court Proceedings
The Allahabad High Court took serious exception to the unauthorised recording of judicial proceedings on a mobile phone after a man was caught recording a hearing without the Court's permission. The Court ordered his custody and directed that litigants shall not be permitted to carry mobile phones into courtrooms.
How the Incident Came to Light
During the hearing, Additional Government Advocate P.K. Singh informed Justice Vikram D. Chauhan that a person was recording the proceedings on his mobile phone without authorisation.
The person, identified as Raj Kulshrestha, admitted recording the proceedings but could not explain why he had done so. Upon examining his mobile phone, the Bench Secretary found three videos of the court proceedings.
The Court further found that Kulshrestha did not have a valid pass to enter the courtroom. He stated that Advocate Bhanu Pratap Seth, a junior of Advocate Nitish Kumar Soni, had brought him to the Court.
Court's Observations on Open Justice
The Court observed that although judicial proceedings are generally open to the public, the principle of open justice does not authorise individuals to record and broadcast court proceedings without permission.
It expressed concern that unauthorised recordings could result in social media trials even before judicial determination, prejudice litigants and expose victims to public stigma.
The Court observed:
"The principle of open justice means proceedings are generally open to the public to attend. However, the same does not amount to 'free broadcast' by any unauthorized individual."
It further held that the Presiding Officer of each Court must regulate the recording and broadcasting of proceedings and that no person has the right to record court proceedings without the Court's permission.
Custody and Restrictions on Mobile Phones
The Court directed that Raj Kulshrestha be taken into custody and produced before the Chief Judicial Magistrate, Prayagraj, after a medical examination. However, the CJM may grant him bail upon furnishing a personal bond and two sureties, subject to his appearance before the High Court on November 20, 2026.
The Court also directed Advocates Nitish Kumar Soni and Bhanu Pratap Seth to appear and explain why proceedings should not be initiated against them for interference with the administration of justice.
In a further direction concerning courtroom security, the Court prohibited litigants from entering courtrooms with mobile phones. It held that the concerned Advocate would be solely responsible if a litigant was found carrying a mobile phone inside the courtroom.
The Registrar General was directed to display notices at the pass counter, while the Registrar (Protocol) was instructed to ensure that appropriate entry restrictions were implemented.
Case Details
Case Name: Kuldeep Batra v. State of U.P. and Another
Court: Allahabad High Court
Date of Decision: November 19, 2026
Case Number: Matters Under Article 227 No. 14284 of 2026
Coram: Justice Vikram D. Chauhan






