Bank's Failure To Disclose Encumbrances
The Calcutta High Court has held that failure by a secured creditor to disclose known encumbrances and pending litigation in an auction sale notice violates the mandatory requirements of the Security Interest (Enforcement) Rules, 2002 and entitles the auction purchaser to seek a full refund of the sale consideration.
Justice Om Narayan Rai passed the ruling while allowing a writ petition filed by an auction purchaser against Punjab National Bank (PNB).
Background of the Case
The dispute arose after Ambhi Impex Private Limited defaulted on credit facilities obtained from the erstwhile Union Bank of India, now PNB. The mortgaged property, consisting of land and a six-storeyed building, was auctioned on September 28, 2022.
The auction purchaser emerged as the highest bidder and paid the entire consideration of ₹5,53,22,000. The Bank issued a sale certificate on February 28, 2023.
However, the sale notice disclosed only symbolic possession and stated that no encumbrances were known to the Bank. It did not disclose pending proceedings before the Debt Recovery Tribunal or the existing tenancy affecting the property. Despite receiving the entire consideration, the Bank failed to deliver physical possession.
The purchaser subsequently sought a refund, but the Bank declined the request.
Court's Observations
The Court observed that Rule 8(7) of the Security Interest (Enforcement) Rules, 2002, read with the proviso to Rule 8(6) and Appendix IV-A, imposes mandatory disclosure requirements concerning encumbrances and other material particulars of the property.
The pending litigation was known to the Bank, and the existing tenancy also constituted a material encumbrance requiring disclosure.
The Court rejected the Bank's contention that the purchaser could not seek a refund without specifically challenging the auction sale. It held that the Bank's failure to comply with mandatory statutory requirements constituted a material irregularity.
The Court further observed that delivery of possession is an essential part of the auction process and that a purchaser cannot be expected to wait indefinitely after paying the entire consideration.
Court's Decision
The Court held that the auction purchaser was entitled to a refund of the entire sale consideration of ₹5,53,22,000. It also declared the sale certificate dated February 28, 2023, to be of no consequence, permitting the Bank to auction the property afresh in accordance with law.
However, considering that the purchaser had delayed seeking a refund after becoming aware of the pending litigation, the Court restricted the interest entitlement. PNB was directed to pay simple interest at the highest fixed deposit rate offered by the Bank, calculated from February 20, 2025, until the date of refund.
In a connected writ petition filed by the Bank, the Court directed the District Magistrate, Purba Burdwan, to dispose of the Bank's application under Section 14 of the SARFAESI Act within one month.
Case Details
Case Name: Sri Ashok Kumar Ghosh v. Punjab National Bank & Others
Court: Calcutta High Court
Date of Decision: 12 November 2026
Case Number: WPA 4255 of 2025 and WPA 15541 of 2025
Coram/Judge: Justice Om Narayan Rai






