Background of the Case

The Bombay High Court has set aside an Order-in-Original passed by the Commissioner of Customs (Import-I), following allegations that the adjudicating authority relied on non-existent Supreme Court judgments apparently generated through Artificial Intelligence (AI), without independently verifying their authenticity.

The proceedings arose from a writ petition filed by Quanta Logistics Private Limited challenging the Order-in-Original dated August 11, 2026.

The petitioner contended that the impugned order contained references to two judgments purportedly delivered by the Supreme Court, which could not be traced in any recognised law report or legal database. According to the petitioner, these judgments appeared to be the result of AI-generated hallucinations.

Petitioner's Contentions

The petitioner argued that the Customs Commissioner's order had been prepared by relying on Artificial Intelligence without the necessary independent application of mind.

As an illustration, the petitioner pointed out that two Supreme Court judgments referred to in the impugned order did not appear to exist.

The petitioner maintained that the authorities had relied upon judicial precedents whose authenticity could not be established.

It was further brought to the Court's attention that the petitioner had addressed a letter dated September 1, 2026, requesting the Commissioner to provide copies of the two judgments relied upon in the order. However, the requested copies were not furnished.

During the proceedings, the petitioner's counsel also relied upon the Supreme Court's decision in Vijay Ghanshyam Gadiya v. Union of India, which dealt with the consequences of relying on fabricated and AI-generated judicial authorities in adjudicatory proceedings.

Supreme Court's Position on AI-Generated Judgments

In Vijay Ghanshyam Gadiya v. Union of India, the Supreme Court had examined a Customs adjudication order imposing a penalty of approximately Rs. 425.27 crore, which contained references to judgments and legal articles allegedly generated through Artificial Intelligence.

Upon independently examining the materials, the Supreme Court found that certain judgments were non-existent or carried fabricated citations. It also discovered instances where existing judgments had been incorrectly attributed with legal propositions that they did not actually establish.

The Supreme Court held that the use of AI-generated material presented as genuine judicial precedents could undermine the integrity of adjudication.

The Court also clarified that Artificial Intelligence can legitimately assist judicial and adjudicatory processes, provided that human supervision and independent verification remain central to decision-making.

Court's Observations on the Use of Artificial Intelligence

The Supreme Court's observations reproduced in the Bombay High Court's order emphasised the distinction between using AI as an assistive technology and allowing it to replace independent adjudication.

The relevant passage reads:

"Notwithstanding that the regulations are yet to be finalised, use of AI as an assistive tool to speed up the decision-making process cannot be denied. However, a note of caution must be sounded: assistance can never be substituted for adjudication. AI may well serve as training wheels but entrusting it with the pilot's seat would be both imprudent and dangerous."

The Supreme Court's observations underline that technological assistance cannot relieve an adjudicating authority of its responsibility to independently examine the facts, verify legal authorities and arrive at its own conclusions.

Respondents Agree to Quashing of the Order

During the hearing before the Bombay High Court, the respondents fairly submitted that the challenged order could be quashed and the matter remitted to the Commissioner of Customs for fresh adjudication.

In view of the submissions made by both parties, the Division Bench agreed to set aside the impugned order.

The Court did not undertake an independent examination of whether the Commissioner had actually used AI to prepare the order or make a separate finding on the alleged generation of the two judgments. The order was set aside by consent of the parties.

Bombay High Court's Final Decision

The Division Bench of Justice M. S. Karnik and Justice Sandesh D. Patil quashed and set aside the Order-in-Original dated August 11, 2026.

The petitioner was directed to appear before the Commissioner of Customs on November 5, 2026, at 11:00 a.m. Thereafter, the Commissioner was directed to fix the next date of hearing.

The Court further directed that the proceedings be concluded within eight weeks from November 5, 2026.

Accordingly, Writ Petition No. 5093 of 2026 was disposed of.

Legal Significance

The proceedings highlight the importance of independently verifying judicial precedents before relying upon them in administrative and quasi-judicial decisions.

Although Artificial Intelligence can assist in legal research, drafting and analysis, an adjudicating authority cannot treat AI-generated case citations or legal propositions as authentic without verification.

The decision also brings attention to the responsibility of authorities exercising statutory powers to ensure that their orders are supported by genuine legal authorities and reflect independent application of mind.

Importantly, the Bombay High Court's order must be understood in its procedural context: the challenged Customs order was quashed with the consent of both parties and the matter was remanded for fresh adjudication, rather than following a contested final determination on the allegation of AI-generated judgments.

Case Details

Case Name: Quanta Logistics Pvt. Ltd. v. Commissioner of Customs (Import-I)

Court: Bombay High Court

Date of Decision: October 30, 2026

Case Number: Writ Petition No. 5093 of 2026

Neutral Citation: 2026:BHC-OS:24069-DB

Coram/Judges: Justice M. S. Karnik and Justice Sandesh D. Patil