Background of the Case

M/s Wide Range Sales Pvt. Ltd. had advanced an inter-corporate deposit of ₹1 crore to Tantia Constructions Limited on June 14, 2012. Towards repayment, the company issued a cheque dated July 1, 2014, which was dishonoured on September 11, 2014, with the endorsement "Exceeds Arrangement".

Following non-payment despite a demand notice, the complainant initiated proceedings under Sections 138 and 141 of the Negotiable Instruments Act, 1881, against the company and 11 individuals associated with it. The Magistrate issued summons on July 20, 2015.

Petitioners' Arguments

The petitioners contended that merely holding positions as directors or company secretary could not attract criminal liability. They argued that the complaint failed to explain their individual roles in the transaction, issuance of the cheque or management of the company's day-to-day affairs.

The complainant opposed the petitions, maintaining that the accused persons were responsible for managing the company's affairs and its financial liabilities.

Court's Observations

Justice Ajay Kumar Gupta observed that vicarious criminal liability under Section 141 of the NI Act depends on whether an individual was in charge of and responsible for the conduct of the company's business when the offence was committed. Merely holding a designation does not automatically attract such liability.

The Court noted that the complaint did not identify the person who signed the dishonoured cheque or attribute any specific role in the transaction to the company secretary and the two independent directors. Documentary records also established that Tarun Chaturvedi and Madhuchhanda Chatterjee were non-executive independent directors.

Referring to Section 149(12) of the Companies Act, 2013, the Court emphasised that independent and certain non-executive directors can be held liable only for acts or omissions occurring with their knowledge, attributable through Board processes, and with their consent or connivance, or where they failed to act diligently.

The Court observed:

"A Director of a company who was not in charge or responsible for the conduct of the business of the company at the relevant time, will not be liable for offence punishable under Section 138/141 of the N.I.Act."

It further held that a specific, direct and distinct role must be attributed to an independent director to establish liability under Section 141(2) of the NI Act.

Final Decision

The High Court quashed the proceedings against company secretary Md. Jamshed Alam and independent directors Tarun Chaturvedi and Madhuchhanda Chatterjee, holding that their prosecution would amount to an abuse of the process of law.

However, the Court refused to quash proceedings against the remaining accused directors, who had failed to produce authenticated documentary evidence establishing their status as independent or non-executive directors. The Court held that the basic averment regarding their responsibility for the company's business was sufficient for the proceedings to continue.

Accordingly, CRR 2828 of 2017 was partly allowed, while CRR 142 of 2016 was allowed.

Case Details

Case Name: Shaleen Khemani & Ors. v. State of West Bengal & Anr.; Tarun Chaturvedi & Anr. v. M/s Wide Range Sales Pvt. Ltd.

Court: Calcutta High Court

Date of Decision: 19 November 2026

Case Numbers: CRR No. 2828 of 2017 and CRR No. 142 of 2016

Coram: Justice Ajay Kumar Gupta