Background of the Case

The petitioner, M/s Shri Ganpati Carring Corporation, a partnership firm engaged in road transportation services in Saharanpur, Uttar Pradesh, was involved in GST proceedings relating to the financial year 2018–19.

The department issued a notice under Section 61 of the GST Act on July 15, 2023, alleging discrepancies in the returns. Subsequently, a show cause notice in Form GST DRC-01 was issued on December 23, 2023, under Rules 100(2) and 142(1)(a), requiring the assessee to submit its reply by January 23, 2024. However, the columns specifying the date, time and venue of personal hearing were marked "N.A."

The Assistant Commissioner passed an order under Section 73 on April 23, 2024, without conducting a personal hearing. The assessee's subsequent appeal was rejected on August 4, 2025, on the ground of a delay of 70 days.

Submissions of the Parties

The assessee contended that the original adjudicating authority was required to provide an opportunity of personal hearing irrespective of whether a written reply had been submitted. It further argued that the appellate order could not survive once the original proceedings were vitiated.

The State opposed the petition, arguing that the assessee had failed to respond to both notices. However, the State's counsel could not dispute that no date, time or venue had been fixed for personal hearing.

Court's Observations

Justice Vikas Budhwar held that failure to submit a reply to a show cause notice does not extinguish the assessee's right to an opportunity of personal hearing.

The Court observed:

"As a matter of fact once a show cause notice is issued then it is for the Assessee either to reply or not and further even in fact in case no reply has been submitted and a column has been earmarked in the show cause notice fixing the date, time and the venue of hearing, then proprietary demanded that the authority in original ought to have fixed date time and venue of personal hearing so as to enable the Assessee to put forward his stand orally though as per the claim set up by the respondents, the reply was not submitted."

The Court held that the failure to provide for a personal hearing undermined the very foundation of the proceedings, rendering the entire proceedings unsustainable.

Court's Decision

The High Court set aside both the original assessment order dated April 23, 2024, and the appellate order dated August 4, 2025, and remitted the matter to the original adjudicating authority.

The assessee was directed to submit its reply by November 13, 2026. The authority was directed to provide a personal hearing during the week commencing November 23, 2026, after giving at least five days' prior notice, and pass a fresh order by December 24, 2026.

The Court clarified that it had not examined the merits of the GST dispute.

Case Details

Case Name: M/s Shri Ganpati Carring Corp v. State of Uttar Pradesh and Others

Court: Allahabad High Court

Date of Decision: November 2, 2026

Case Number: Writ Tax No. 4352 of 2026

Coram/Judge: Justice Vikas Budhwar