Background of the Case

The Karnataka High Court dismissed a criminal petition filed by a woman seeking to quash an FIR registered by Belthangady Police under Sections 353(2) and 62 of the Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita, 2023.

The complaint alleged that the woman had attempted to run over the complainant with an autorickshaw on April 16, 2024, and had subsequently published threatening and defamatory messages about him on Instagram.

The complainant also alleged that the woman had posted his photograph showing him lying in a hospital bed, accompanied by an inappropriate message.

Arguments Before the Court

The petitioner denied the alleged incident and contended that the autorickshaw driver had not been made an accused in the present case.

The State submitted that a separate FIR had already been registered against the autorickshaw driver and a chargesheet had been filed in that matter. It further pointed to the Instagram posts and other alleged threatening messages as grounds warranting investigation.

Court's Observations

Justice Suraj Govindaraj observed that the availability of social media platforms does not give individuals unrestricted freedom to publish anything they wish.

The Court remarked:

"A social media handle being available would not give a free license to any person to post any message that a person wants. The messages which are posted ought to be within the exercise and limits of Article 19(1)(a) of the Constitution."

The Court further observed that the photograph of the complainant lying in a hospital bed, together with the accompanying message, indicated at that stage that the allegations could not be treated as false.

However, it clarified that the truth of the allegations and their extent would have to be established through investigation.

Final Decision

Noting that the allegations were serious enough to warrant investigation, the High Court refused to interfere with the FIR. It also observed that an earlier interim order had prevented the investigation from progressing.

Accordingly, the criminal petition was dismissed, and the police were directed to complete the necessary investigation at the earliest and submit their report.

Case Details

Case Name: Shubha v. State of Karnataka & Another

Court: Karnataka High Court

Date of Decision: October 15, 2026

Case Number: Criminal Petition No. 7143 of 2025

Coram: Justice Suraj Govindaraj