Background of the Case
The Jammu & Kashmir and Ladakh High Court was considering two petitions filed by a property dealer seeking quashing of proceedings under Section 138 of the Negotiable Instruments Act, 1881.
The dispute arose from a proposed sale of land at Nagrota, Udhampur, for ₹83 lakh. The purchasers allegedly paid advances of ₹12 lakh and ₹16 lakh respectively. After discovering an existing dispute over the property, the transaction was cancelled, and the petitioner agreed to refund the amounts.
Towards repayment, the petitioner issued cheques which were dishonoured. Following service of demand notices on July 15, 2022, the purchasers instituted complaints on July 29, 2022. The Magistrate took cognizance and issued process on July 30, 2022.
Arguments of the Parties
The petitioner argued that the complaints were premature since they were filed before expiry of the statutory 15-day period available for payment after receipt of the demand notice. He also challenged the composite notices, alleged part-payment of the cheque amounts and questioned compliance with Section 202 CrPC.
The respondents opposed the petitions, contending that the complaints were maintainable and that the alleged part-payments related to separate outstanding liabilities.
Court's Observations
Justice Yash Paul Bourney observed that although the complaints were presented one day before expiry of the statutory period, the Magistrate took cognizance only after the 15-day period had expired.
The Court held:
"Thus, even if no cause of action had accrued on the date of filing of the complaints, still by the time the complaints were considered and cognizance was taken by the learned Magistrate, the statutory period had expired."
The Court further noted that the petitioner had not demonstrated any willingness to pay the cheque amounts during the subsequent proceedings, which had continued for more than four years. It therefore found that no prejudice had been caused merely because the complaints were presented a day earlier.
Final Decision
The High Court dismissed both petitions and upheld the Magistrate's orders taking cognizance and issuing process against the petitioner.
Important Legal Position
The High Court's reasoning requires consideration alongside the Supreme Court's three-Judge Bench decision in Yogendra Pratap Singh v. Savitri Pandey (2014). The Supreme Court expressly held that a complaint filed before expiry of the 15-day statutory period is not maintainable, even if cognizance is taken after the period expires.
The Supreme Court specifically rejected the contrary interpretation that subsequent expiry of the statutory period cures premature filing. Accordingly, the proposition adopted by the High Court in the present case appears inconsistent with the binding Supreme Court ruling.
Case Details
Case Name: Yudhvir Singh Katoch v. Basharat Khan and Another
Court: High Court of Jammu & Kashmir and Ladakh at Srinagar
Date of Decision: 28.10.2026
Case Number: CRM(M) No. 206/2023 c/w CRM(M) No. 207/2023
Coram/Judge: Justice Yash Paul Bourney






