Background of the Case

In Sri Chandan G v. State of Karnataka, the petitioner suffered permanent spinal injuries and traumatic paraplegia after a dangerous Gulmohar tree branch fell on him while he was travelling on a Bengaluru public road on 7 March 2024.

Prior Notice and Negligence

The school management had informed the BBMP about the dangerous branch on 22 February 2024. Despite receiving the complaint, the BBMP failed to take preventive action before the accident. Permission for removal was granted only on the day of the incident.

The Court held that failure to act despite specific prior notice amounted to negligence and attracted municipal liability.

Maintainability Under Article 226

The respondents argued that the petitioner should approach the civil court for compensation.

Rejecting this objection, the High Court held that an alternative civil remedy does not automatically bar compensation under Article 226 where statutory duty, prior notice, failure to act and resulting injury are established through documentary evidence.

Right to Safe Public Roads

The Court recognised public road safety as an aspect of the fundamental right to life under Article 21. It held that municipal authorities must address known public safety hazards, even where the dangerous tree is situated on private property.

Compensation

Considering the petitioner's permanent disability, medical expenses and loss of earning capacity, the Court awarded ₹2,77,29,695 with 6% annual interest from 7 March 2024 until payment.

The BBMP was granted liberty to seek contribution from the school through appropriate proceedings. The school was also directed to provide free education to the petitioner's daughter until completion of the 12th standard.

Legal Significance

The judgment establishes that compensation can be awarded under Article 226 without requiring a separate civil suit where:

  1. A public authority owes a statutory duty.

  2. Prior notice of the danger is established.

  3. The authority fails to take timely preventive action.

  4. The failure has a direct connection with the injury.

  5. Sufficient documentary evidence establishes the essential facts.

The decision is significant for victims seeking compensation for injuries caused by municipal negligence and failure to address known public safety hazards.

Case Details

Case: Sri Chandan G v. State of Karnataka

Court: High Court of Karnataka, Bengaluru

Date: 18 September 2026

Case No.: W.P. No. 31629/2024 (LB-BMP)

Neutral Citation: 2026:KHC:51190

Judge: Justice Suraj Govindaraj