Background of the Case
The Karnataka High Court was considering a writ petition filed by police officer Laxman K. Pawar challenging orders passed by the Karnataka State Human Rights Commission (KSHRC), which had recommended disciplinary proceedings against him under the Karnataka State Police (Disciplinary Proceedings) Rules, 1965.
The proceedings arose from a complaint filed by Ashish Kohli, who alleged that he was harassed and illegally detained at a police station.
An initial inquiry by a Deputy Superintendent of Police found no substance in the allegations. However, a subsequent inquiry by another officer found that Kohli had been taken to the police station and detained without any written complaint or FIR. The subsequent inquiry also found allegations concerning receipt of ₹40,000 to be established.
Based on the subsequent report, the Commission recommended disciplinary proceedings against the police officer.
Arguments Before the Court
The petitioner contended that complaints involving illegal detention and custodial torture must be heard by a Division Bench of the Commission under Regulation 11(4) of the Karnataka State Human Rights Commission (Procedure) Regulations, 2007.
The Commission opposed the contention, arguing that the 2007 Regulations had been repealed by the 2020 Regulations and that the relevant procedural requirement was directory rather than mandatory.
High Court's Observations
Justice T.P. Vivekananda examined Regulation 11(4), which provides that complaints concerning custodial death, custodial torture, custodial rape and illegal detention shall normally be heard by a Division Bench.
The Court held that the expression 'normally' refers to the usual procedure and permits exceptions only where specifically directed by the Chairperson. Therefore, assigning such a complaint to a Single Bench requires a special order from the Chairperson.
The Court observed:
"The word normally depicted in regulation (4) of Regulation 11, will have to be understood as in usual course. If there has been an exception to the normal course, then special order at the hands of the Chairperson was necessary."
It further clarified that even where procedural provisions permit exceptions, administrative or quasi-judicial authorities cannot depart from the prescribed procedure arbitrarily.
Final Decision
The High Court allowed the writ petition, quashed the Commission's orders dated 29.11.2022 and 26.02.2024, and remitted the matter to the Karnataka State Human Rights Commission for fresh adjudication by a Division Bench.
Importantly, the Court did not examine the merits of the allegations against the police officer, leaving all contentions open for consideration by the Commission.
Case Details
Case Name: Sri Laxman K. Pawar v. The Karnataka State Human Rights Commission & Another
Court: Karnataka High Court, Bengaluru
Date of Decision: 05 November 2026
Case Number: Writ Petition No. 10474 of 2024
Coram/Judge: Justice T.P. Vivekananda






