Background of the Case

The Karnataka High Court, Kalaburagi Bench, was considering an appeal filed by the North Eastern Karnataka Road Transport Corporation (NEKRTC) challenging a Motor Accident Claims Tribunal award directing it to pay ₹2,30,443 as compensation to an injured motorcyclist.

The accident occurred on September 11, 2017, when the claimant's motorcycle collided with a NEKRTC bus. The Tribunal had attributed negligence to the bus driver and awarded compensation.

NEKRTC challenged the award, contending that the claimant was riding without a valid driving licence or insurance policy and was carrying two pillion riders, amounting to triple riding.

Court's Observations on Negligence

Justice K.V. Aravind observed that the claimant had failed to produce his driving licence, the motorcycle was uninsured and he was carrying two pillion riders.

The Court further noted that the accident occurred in the middle of the road, with sufficient space available for the motorcycle to pass safely. It held that merely filing a charge sheet against the bus driver could not conclusively establish negligence.

Observing that the Motor Vehicles Act, 1988, being beneficial legislation, could not be interpreted to condone violations of its mandatory provisions, the Court attributed 50% contributory negligence to the claimant.

Insurance Mandatory Before Release Of Seized Vehicles

The Court expressed concern that vehicles involved in accidents were routinely released after inspection and imposition of fines, even when violations such as absence of valid insurance or driving licences were detected.

It observed that releasing uninsured vehicles without ensuring compliance would allow statutory violations to continue and could seriously prejudice accident victims seeking compensation.

The Court also referred to the Supreme Court's decisions in Oriental Insurance Co. Ltd. v. Tuni Pati and National Insurance Co. Ltd. v. Thungala Dhana Laxmi, concerning fraudulent motor accident claims and the widespread use of uninsured vehicles.

Directions To Police And Courts

The High Court issued the following directions:

1. The Director General and Inspector General of Police shall instruct all police authorities across Karnataka to release seized vehicles involved in any offence only after production of a valid insurance policy covering the vehicle.

2. All jurisdictional courts shall ensure that seized vehicles are released only upon production of a valid insurance policy.

3. The police authorities shall submit a compliance report before the High Court on December 14, 2026.

4. The Registrar General shall circulate the order to all jurisdictional courts for necessary compliance.

Final Decision

The High Court partly allowed NEKRTC's appeal and modified the Tribunal's award. It maintained the claimant's entitlement to compensation of ₹2,30,443 with interest at 6% per annum and directed the Corporation to deposit 50% of the compensation, along with proportionate interest, within eight weeks.

The Tribunal's directions concerning release and investment of the compensation amount were maintained.

Case Details

Case Name: The Divisional Controller, NEKRTC v. Marenna @ Mareppa

Court: Karnataka High Court, Kalaburagi Bench

Date of Decision: 02.09.2026

Case Number: MFA No. 200595 of 2023

Coram/Judge: Justice K.V. Aravind

Neutral Citation: 2026:KHC-K:9088