Background of the Case
The Madhya Pradesh High Court was considering an appeal seeking enhancement of compensation awarded by the Motor Accident Claims Tribunal (MACT), Bhind, following the death of a minor boy, Harendra Singh Baghel, in a road accident on December 24, 2019.
The Claims Tribunal, by its award dated September 14, 2022, in Motor Accident Claim Case No. 43 of 2020, had awarded compensation of ₹5,45,000 with interest at 6% per annum.
While calculating the compensation, the Tribunal determined the deceased's age as 14 years, 7 months and 9 days based on his Aadhaar card.
The claimants, who were the deceased's parents, approached the High Court seeking enhancement of the compensation.
Arguments of the Parties
The counsel appearing for the claimants argued that the Tribunal had incorrectly assessed the deceased's notional monthly income at ₹25,000. According to them, the income should have been calculated based on the minimum wages payable to an unskilled worker prevailing on the date of the accident, amounting to ₹7,950 per month.
The insurance company challenged the Tribunal's determination of the deceased's age. It contended that the Aadhaar card could not be treated as conclusive proof of age and that the post-mortem report had recorded the deceased's age as 13 years.
The insurance company further argued that the Tribunal had incorrectly applied a multiplier of 18. Relying on the Supreme Court's decisions in Meena Devi v. Nunu Chand Mahto and Rajendra Singh v. National Insurance Company Limited, it contended that a multiplier of 15 was applicable to a deceased person below 15 years of age.
In response, the claimants relied upon the Supreme Court's decision in Ku. Aarti v. Udayveer Singh, as well as a subsequent decision of the Madhya Pradesh High Court, to support the application of a multiplier of 18 even in cases involving the death of a minor.
Whether Aadhaar Card Can Establish Age Conclusively
The principal issue concerning the deceased's age was whether the Aadhaar card or the post-mortem report provided a more reliable basis for determining his age at the time of the accident.
The High Court examined the documents relied upon by the Claims Tribunal. It found that the Aadhaar card indicated the deceased's age as 14 years, 7 months and 9 days, whereas the post-mortem report (Ex.P10) recorded his age as 13 years.
Justice Amit Seth observed that an Aadhaar card is primarily an identity document and cannot, by itself, be treated as conclusive proof of the holder's age.
The Court gave greater evidentiary weight to the post-mortem report because the age mentioned therein was based on medical assessment conducted during the post-mortem examination.
Consequently, considering the circumstances of the case, the High Court accepted the medical opinion recorded in the post-mortem report and determined the deceased's age as 13 years at the time of the accident.
Determination of the Appropriate Multiplier
After determining the deceased's age as 13 years, the High Court examined the appropriate multiplier for calculating compensation.
The insurance company contended that a multiplier of 15 was applicable to victims aged up to 15 years, relying upon the Supreme Court's decisions in Divya v. The National Insurance Company Limited and Meena Devi v. Nunu Chand Mahto.
The Court examined the legal position laid down by the Supreme Court in Reshma Kumari v. Madan Mohan, wherein a three-Judge Bench had approved the application of a multiplier of 15 in cases involving deceased persons aged up to 15 years.
The High Court also considered the relevant observations in National Insurance Company Limited v. Pranay Sethi, which approved the multiplier system laid down in Sarla Verma v. Delhi Transport Corporation.
Relying upon these decisions, the Court held that a multiplier of 15 was appropriate in the present case, as the deceased was below 15 years of age.
It therefore rejected the application of the multiplier of 18 adopted by the Claims Tribunal.
Recalculation of Compensation
The High Court accepted the claimants' contention that the deceased's notional income should be assessed with reference to the minimum wages payable to an unskilled worker.
Accordingly, the monthly income was fixed at ₹7,950, resulting in an annual income of ₹95,400.
After deducting 50% towards the deceased's personal and living expenses, the annual loss of dependency was calculated at ₹47,700.
Applying the multiplier of 15, the loss of dependency was determined at ₹7,15,500.
The Court additionally awarded ₹40,000 each to the deceased's parents towards loss of parental consortium, amounting to ₹80,000 collectively.
A further amount of ₹15,000 was awarded towards funeral expenses and ₹15,000 towards loss of estate.
The total compensation was consequently recalculated as follows:
- Loss of dependency: ₹7,15,500
- Loss of parental consortium: ₹80,000
- Funeral expenses: ₹15,000
- Loss of estate: ₹15,000
The total compensation payable was fixed at ₹8,25,500, as against the earlier award of ₹5,45,000.
Accordingly, the claimants became entitled to an additional compensation of ₹2,80,500.
Final Decision of the High Court
The Madhya Pradesh High Court partly allowed the claimants' appeal and also allowed the insurance company's cross-objections to the extent of correcting the deceased's age and applying the appropriate multiplier.
The Court directed that the enhanced compensation of ₹2,80,500 would carry interest at the rate of 6% per annum, as awarded by the Tribunal, from the date of filing of the claim petition until actual realisation.
The remaining terms and conditions of the Tribunal's award were left undisturbed.
The appeal and the connected cross-objections were accordingly disposed of.
Relevant Extract from the Judgment
The High Court observed:
"An Aadhaar Card is primarily an identity document and cannot, by itself, be treated as conclusive proof of the age of its holder. On the other hand, the age recorded in the postmortem report is based upon medical assessment conducted in the course of postmortem examination. Therefore, in the facts and circumstances of the present case, this Court finds the medical opinion recorded in the postmortem report to be a more reliable basis for determining the age of the deceased."
The observation clarifies that an Aadhaar card, although useful for establishing identity, does not automatically establish a person's age conclusively. The evidentiary value of the available documents must be examined in the circumstances of the particular case.
Case Details
Case Name: Rajesh Singh and Another v. Rahul Singh and Others
Court: High Court of Madhya Pradesh, Gwalior Bench
Date of Decision: November 3, 2026
Case Number: Miscellaneous Appeal No. 6071 of 2022
Neutral Citation: 2026:MPHC-GWL:33646
Coram/Judge: Justice Amit Seth






