Background of the Case
The Karnataka High Court has upheld the Family Court's decision permitting a mother, an ophthalmologist, to take her 11-year-old son to the United Kingdom, where she secured employment.
The parties married in 2013 and have been living separately since 2019, with the child remaining in the mother's custody. The mother subsequently secured a professional opportunity in the UK and sought the father's cooperation in obtaining the child's passport and visa.
The Family Court allowed her application under Section 26 of the Hindu Marriage Act, 1955, and directed the father to cooperate with the necessary travel formalities.
Father's Challenge
The father challenged the Family Court's orders before the High Court, contending that permission to relocate the child had not been specifically sought in the original application. He also alleged parental alienation and argued that the mother's temporary departure to the UK, leaving the child with maternal relatives in India due to visa delays, justified transferring interim custody to him.
Court's Observations
Justice Lalitha Kanneganti rejected the father's objections, observing that the substance and purpose of the mother's application had to be considered rather than examining its prayer in isolation.
The Court distinguished between granting an entirely new relief without notice to the opposite party and granting relief that gives effect to the actual purpose of an application.
On the mother's temporary separation from the child, the Court held that leaving the child with maternal relatives because of pending travel formalities did not, by itself, amount to abandonment or justify transferring custody.
Emphasising a woman's professional freedom, the Court observed:
"Marriage and motherhood do not deprive a woman of the freedom to pursue professional opportunities or require her to remain confined to a particular place. A mother who has been raising a child cannot be compelled to choose between retaining custody and pursuing her profession merely because the opportunity available to her is in another country."
The Court further observed that geographical separation and parental alienation are not synonymous. The mere fact that a child resides abroad with one parent does not establish that the other parent is being excluded from the child's life.
It also considered the child's expressed willingness to accompany his mother while maintaining his relationship with his father.
Final Decision
The High Court dismissed the father's challenge to the Family Court's custody arrangements and permitted the mother to take the child to the UK.
To preserve the father's relationship with the child, the Court directed the mother to facilitate telephone or video communication for at least 20 minutes daily. The child must also spend 75% of his school vacations with the father twice a year, either in India or during the father's visit to the UK.
Both parents were directed to cooperate in maintaining the child's relationship with the other parent. The custody and parenting arrangements remain subject to modification by the competent court in the child's welfare.
Case Details
Case Name: Rithvik Hegde v. Dr. Shivani Hegde
Court: High Court of Karnataka, Bengaluru
Date of Decision: 29.10.2026
Case Number: W.P. No. 37759 of 2025 c/w W.P. No. 38415 of 2025 and W.P. No. 14682 of 2026
Coram/Judge: Justice Lalitha Kanneganti






