Background of the Case

The Patna High Court allowed an appeal filed by Lalita Devi challenging an order confiscating her movable and immovable properties and those of her late husband, Dwarika Nath Rai, a former Superintending Engineer in Bihar's Public Health Engineering Department.

The proceedings arose from a vigilance case registered in 1995, alleging that her husband had acquired disproportionate assets worth approximately ₹13.14 lakh during the check period from February 1963 to May 1989. Lalita Devi was also implicated on allegations of abetting the acquisition of such assets. However, the criminal proceedings against her were subsequently quashed in 2009.

The confiscation order was passed on September 30, 2016, despite her husband's death on March 31, 2016.

Agricultural Income Cannot Be Excluded

Justice Chandra Shekhar Jha observed that the authorities had failed to properly consider the legitimate sources of income disclosed by the family.

The deceased officer had submitted documents establishing ownership of 22.30 acres of inherited agricultural land. A certificate issued by the Circle Officer, Charpokhari, estimated agricultural income at ₹70,000 per month, amounting to ₹18.90 lakh during the check period.

However, the authorised officer rejected this income due to the absence of income tax returns and what was considered insufficient evidence of actual agricultural earnings.

The High Court found this approach arbitrary, particularly because affidavits of persons involved in cultivating the land had also been disregarded.

The Court further noted that Lalita Devi's agricultural income, rental income and housing loan had not been properly considered despite their disclosure in her income tax return filed in March 1989.

It held:

“Thus, this Court is of the considered view that nonconsideration of the agricultural income of the appellant is bad in the eyes of law in view of Nirankar Nath Pandey case (supra).”

Properties Outside the Check Period

The Court also identified irregularities in the valuation and inclusion of assets. Certain movable properties were included based on an inventory prepared in April 1995, beyond the relevant check period. The construction of the second floor of the house, completed after the check period, had also not been properly accounted for.

Effect of Death on Confiscation Proceedings

The Court further examined whether confiscation proceedings could continue after the death of the public servant.

Relying on the relevant principles laid down by the Supreme Court, including the distinction between abatement and acquittal, the High Court considered that the deceased officer had been denied an opportunity to participate in a fair enquiry.

It observed:

“If the trial abates after the death of the accused, then, certainly, the confiscation proceedings, being essentially in the nature of an inquiry, ought also to come to an end upon the death of the delinquent public servant.”

The Court also noted that Lalita Devi had already been discharged from the criminal proceedings, and her discharge had attained the status of acquittal for the purposes of the confiscation proceedings.

Final Decision

Finding serious legal infirmities in the confiscation order, the High Court set it aside and allowed the appeal.

The decision underscores the importance of considering all substantiated lawful sources of income, including agricultural income, while determining disproportionate assets. It also addresses the limits of continuing confiscation proceedings after the death of the public servant.

Case Details

Case Name: Smt. Lalita Devi v. The State of Bihar

Court: Patna High Court

Date of Decision: 29 August 2026

Case Number: Criminal Appeal (SJ) No. 898 of 2016

Coram/Judge: Justice Chandra Shekhar Jha