Background of the Case

The Telangana High Court passed the order while dealing with Contempt Case No.2900 of 2025, initiated by two landowners, Mrs. P. Shivaleela and another, against C. Narayana Reddy, the District Collector of Ranga Reddy District.

The dispute concerned certain plots situated at Manne Muthyalamma Kunta, Turkayamjal Village, Abdullapurmet Mandal, Ranga Reddy District. The petitioners sought deletion of their plots from the prohibitory properties list maintained under Section 22-A of the Registration Act, 1908, so that transactions relating to the properties could be registered.

The petitioners relied on earlier proceedings issued by the then District Collector on August 27, 2022, and a consequential memorandum dated September 2, 2022, through which certain neighbouring plots had been deleted from the prohibitory list.

Earlier High Court Directions

The petitioners had approached the High Court through Writ Petition No.22093 of 2025, complaining that their representations dated March 14, 2024, seeking issuance of No Objection Certificates and deletion of the subject plots from the prohibitory properties list, had not been considered.

On August 5, 2025, the High Court disposed of the writ petition by directing the District Collector to consider the representation in accordance with the earlier proceedings dated August 27, 2022, and the consequential memorandum dated September 2, 2022.

The Court specifically directed that if the Collector was not inclined to accept the request, he should pass a reasoned order and communicate the same to the petitioners.

The entire exercise was required to be completed within 60 days from the date of receipt of the order.

Initiation of Contempt Proceedings

According to the High Court, the order was served on the District Collector on August 11, 2025. Consequently, the 60-day period expired on October 10, 2025.

As the Collector failed to comply with the direction within the stipulated period, the petitioners initiated contempt proceedings on October 15, 2025.

The Court observed that the Collector initiated action only after the contempt proceedings were instituted. Notices were issued to the petitioners, and a rejection order was subsequently passed on February 26, 2026.

Even after further consideration, the Collector passed another rejection order on July 8, 2026, following the Court's direction to reconsider the representation.

Collector's Defence

The District Collector primarily contended that the lands could not be removed from the prohibitory properties list under Section 22-A of the Registration Act, 1908, because the procedure prescribed under Rules 10-A(6), 10-A(7) and 10-A(8) of the Andhra Pradesh Land Reforms (Ceiling on Agricultural Holdings) Rules, 1974, had not been followed.

It was argued that although the Land Reforms Tribunal had passed an order on January 5, 2004, deleting certain lands from the ceiling purview, the Revenue Divisional Officer and the Tahsildar had not completed the prescribed procedure for restoring possession to the declarant through a panchanama in Form XI-A.

The Collector therefore maintained that the subject lands could not be de-notified without completion of the statutory procedure.

High Court's Observations

Justice K. Lakshman observed that the contempt proceedings were concerned with determining whether the Collector had wilfully disobeyed the earlier judicial direction. The Collector could not use the contempt proceedings to reopen issues that ought to have been raised in the original writ proceedings or challenged before an appropriate appellate forum.

The Court also referred to the fact that the neighbouring plots had already been removed from the prohibitory properties list pursuant to earlier High Court directions. Those directions had attained finality, as the State authorities had not challenged them.

The Court noted that the earlier order dated August 5, 2025, had been passed after hearing both sides. The Collector had neither raised the present objections during those proceedings nor challenged the order subsequently.

The High Court further observed that the Collector had failed to explain why Survey No.537 had been deleted from the prohibitory list while Survey Nos.536, 657 and 658 continued to remain in the list.

It also noticed discrepancies in the Collector's affidavits concerning the steps allegedly taken to comply with the judicial direction. In particular, the relevant hearing record dated February 21, 2026, contained blank signature columns for the Revenue Divisional Officer, Tahsildar and Authorised Officer, although the Collector's explanation suggested that the authorities had participated in the proceedings.

The Court also noted that the Collector had failed to produce relevant supporting documents despite relying upon certain administrative proceedings in his defence.

Judicial Orders Must Be Obeyed Even If Considered Incorrect

The High Court relied upon the Supreme Court's decision in Union of India v. Subedar Devassy P.V. (2006) to reiterate that a party cannot refuse to comply with a judicial order merely because it considers the order legally incorrect or difficult to implement.

The Court emphasised that an aggrieved party must approach the court that passed the order or invoke the appropriate appellate jurisdiction rather than disregard the direction and subsequently defend its non-compliance in contempt proceedings.

The relevant observation of the Supreme Court, reproduced by the High Court, reads:

"Rightness or wrongness of the order cannot be urged in contempt proceedings. Right or wrong, the order has to be obeyed. Flouting an order of the court would render the party liable for contempt."

The High Court further relied upon Jalim Singh v. Nand Kishore (2026), observing that contempt jurisdiction is confined to examining compliance with the operative directions in the original order and cannot be used to reopen issues that have already attained finality.

Requirement Of Wilful And Deliberate Disobedience

The Court reiterated that mere non-compliance with a judicial direction is not, by itself, sufficient to attract punishment for contempt. The court must be satisfied that the disobedience was wilful and deliberate.

Referring to the principles laid down by the Supreme Court, the High Court explained that contempt jurisdiction must be exercised with caution and that the circumstances surrounding the alleged violation must be examined before imposing punishment.

In the present case, the Collector had knowledge of the order, had been granted 60 days to comply, and had failed to take the required action within that period. The subsequent rejection orders were passed only after the contempt proceedings had been initiated.

The Court found that the explanations offered by the Collector were unsatisfactory and did not justify the failure to comply with the judicial direction.

Final Decision And Punishment

Allowing the contempt petition, the Telangana High Court held that the District Collector had committed wilful and deliberate disobedience of its order dated August 5, 2025, passed in Writ Petition No.22093 of 2025.

Exercising its powers under Section 12 of the Contempt of Courts Act, 1971, the Court sentenced the Collector to six months' simple imprisonment and imposed a fine of ₹2,000.

However, the Court suspended the sentence of imprisonment for four weeks from the date of the order. The fine was also directed to be paid within four weeks.

The decision reiterates that administrative authorities, including senior government officials, are bound to comply with judicial directions. A public authority cannot disregard a court order on the ground that it considers the direction legally incorrect or that administrative procedures make compliance difficult.

Case Details

Case Name: Smt. P. Shivaleela and Another v. C. Narayana Reddy

Court: High Court for the State of Telangana

Date of Decision: October 30, 2026

Case Number: Contempt Case No.2900 of 2025

CNR Number: HBHC010624912025

Coram/Judge: Justice K. Lakshman