Background of the Case

The Supreme Court is considering petitions filed by the Network of Women in Media, India, the Free Speech Collective, the Delhi Union of Journalists and the Kerala Union of Working Journalists. The petitions raise allegations that journalists were obstructed, detained and harassed by Delhi Police while covering protests against Chief Election Commissioner Gyanesh Kumar at Jantar Mantar.

The proceedings follow the Supreme Court's order dated October 11, 2026, which recorded an assurance that journalists, lawyers and other professionals would not be prevented from discharging their professional duties.

Delhi Police's Submissions

In its counter-affidavit filed through Joint Commissioner of Police Surender Kumar, Delhi Police argued that the protection extended to journalists should not automatically cover social media influencers and reel-makers.

The police submitted that several individuals carrying cameras and microphones were creating social media content or participating in protests, making it difficult for officers to distinguish working journalists from other participants.

It argued that the predominant intention behind an individual's activities could be relevant in determining whether the person was functioning as a journalist or merely creating content for commercial purposes.

The police also maintained that its directions were not intended to obstruct genuine journalistic activities and that reel-makers and influencers could not claim exemption from general laws or lawful police directions at prohibited assemblies.

Independent Journalists Also Have Constitutional Protection

Importantly, the Delhi Police clarified that Press Information Bureau (PIB) accreditation is not mandatory for recognising journalistic work. Identity cards issued by media organisations are also accepted under its October 5 guidelines.

The affidavit acknowledged that independent journalists, freelancers and citizens reporting through YouTube and other digital platforms enjoy constitutional freedoms to gather and publish news.

The police denied deliberately obstructing journalists or seizing their professional equipment and sought dismissal of the petitions.

Legal Significance

The proceedings raise an important question concerning the distinction between journalism and social media content creation in the digital age. However, the question of whether reel-makers and influencers qualify for the same protections as journalists remains to be examined by the Supreme Court.

The Delhi Police's submissions are not a final judicial determination on the legal status or rights of social media content creators.

Case Details

Case Name: Network of Women in Media, India v. Union of India & Ors. and connected matters

Court: Supreme Court of India

Case Number: W.P. (C) No. 1361/2026

Date of Decision: No final decision on this issue reported as on November 19, 2026.