Constitutional Requirement to Communicate Grounds of Arrest
Article 22(1) of the Constitution of India guarantees every person arrested the right to be informed, as soon as possible, of the grounds of arrest. This safeguard enables an arrested person to understand why their liberty has been curtailed, consult a lawyer, challenge the arrest and seek appropriate legal remedies.
The corresponding statutory requirement is contained in Section 47 of the Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita, 2023 (BNSS), which requires the police to communicate the grounds of arrest and inform the arrested person of the right to bail, where applicable.
An important question that has emerged in recent Supreme Court decisions is whether communicating the grounds orally or through arrest-related documents is sufficient, or whether the police must invariably furnish a separate written document containing the grounds of arrest.
The Supreme Court has adopted different approaches to this question, particularly concerning the consequences of failure to furnish written grounds and whether an accused must establish prejudice resulting from such failure.
Pankaj Bansal v. Union of India: Written Grounds Must Be Furnished
In Pankaj Bansal v. Union of India, the Supreme Court examined the requirement of communicating grounds of arrest under the Prevention of Money Laundering Act, 2002 (PMLA).
The Court held that merely reading out the grounds of arrest to an accused would not satisfy the constitutional requirement. A copy of the written grounds of arrest must be furnished to the arrested person as a matter of course and without exception.
The Court emphasised that written communication serves an important purpose. It prevents disputes between the investigating agency and the arrested person regarding whether the grounds were actually communicated. It also enables the accused to understand the basis of the arrest and effectively consult legal counsel and pursue bail remedies.
This decision established a clear requirement of furnishing written grounds in cases governed by the PMLA.
Prabir Purkayastha v. State (NCT of Delhi): Requirement Extended to UAPA Cases
The Supreme Court subsequently considered the same constitutional safeguard in Prabir Purkayastha v. State (NCT of Delhi).
The case concerned an arrest under the Unlawful Activities (Prevention) Act, 1967 (UAPA). The Court reiterated that communicating the grounds of arrest in writing is a fundamental constitutional requirement.
It emphasised that the obligation under Article 22(1), read with the relevant statutory provisions, cannot be disregarded.
The Court observed:
"the requirement to communicate the grounds of arrest or the grounds of detention in writing to a person arrested in connection with an offence or a person placed under preventive detention as provided under Articles 22(1) and 22(5) of the Constitution of India is sacrosanct and cannot be breached under any situation."
The Court further held that non-compliance with this requirement would render the custody or detention illegal.
The decision strengthened the principle that an arrested person must receive written grounds rather than merely being informed orally.
Vihaan Kumar v. State of Haryana: Written Communication Described as the Ideal Course
A different formulation emerged in Vihaan Kumar v. State of Haryana.
The Supreme Court recognised that Article 22(1) does not expressly prescribe that the grounds of arrest must invariably be communicated in writing.
Nevertheless, the Court endorsed the approach suggested in Pankaj Bansal, observing that written communication is the proper and ideal method of informing an arrested person about the grounds of arrest.
The Court explained that the investigating officer must necessarily formulate the grounds before communicating them. Therefore, providing them in writing should ordinarily be practicable.
However, it acknowledged that written communication may not be practicable in every situation.
The Court emphasised that the police must scrupulously comply with Article 22 and ensure that the arrested person is effectively informed of the reasons for the arrest.
Another important aspect of this judgment was the burden of establishing compliance. The Court held that when an arrested person alleges that the grounds were not communicated, the responsibility to establish compliance with Article 22(1) rests upon the police authorities.
The judgment thus distinguished between the mandatory constitutional obligation to communicate the grounds of arrest and the preferred method of fulfilling that obligation.
Kasireddy Upender Reddy v. State of Andhra Pradesh: Emphasis on Effective Communication
In Kasireddy Upender Reddy v. State of Andhra Pradesh, the Supreme Court adopted an approach focusing on the purpose of communicating the grounds of arrest.
The case involved an arrest pursuant to a warrant. The Court considered whether the arrested person was required to be separately furnished with written grounds when the warrant itself communicated the basis for the arrest.
The Court held that a separate written communication was not necessary in those circumstances because the arrest warrant itself conveyed the relevant grounds.
The decision emphasised that the primary constitutional requirement is to ensure that the arrested person understands why they are being arrested.
The Court recognised written communication as the proper and ideal course but did not treat it as an indispensable requirement in every conceivable situation.
The judgment therefore highlighted the distinction between the obligation to communicate the grounds of arrest, which is mandatory, and the precise form in which that obligation must be fulfilled.
Mihir Rajesh Shah v. State of Maharashtra: Written Communication Made Mandatory
The Supreme Court subsequently adopted a more categorical position in Mihir Rajesh Shah v. State of Maharashtra.
The Court held that the grounds of arrest must be communicated in writing to the arrested person in a language that they understand.
Importantly, the requirement was extended beyond cases involving special statutes such as the PMLA and UAPA. The Court clarified that the constitutional safeguard applies to arrests under all offences and statutes.
The Court laid down the following requirements:
1. The grounds of arrest must be communicated in writing in a language understood by the arrested person.
2. Where written communication cannot be provided immediately or soon after arrest, the grounds may initially be communicated orally.
3. In such circumstances, written grounds must subsequently be furnished within a reasonable time and, in any event, at least two hours before the arrested person is produced before the Magistrate for remand proceedings.
4. Failure to comply with these requirements would render the arrest and subsequent remand illegal, entitling the arrested person to be released.
This judgment substantially strengthened the requirement of written communication and provided a specific time framework for compliance.
Jaskaran Jeet Singh Deol v. State of Punjab: Written Grounds Reaffirmed as Mandatory
In Jaskaran Jeet Singh Deol v. State of Punjab, decided on September 21, 2026, the Supreme Court again emphasised the mandatory nature of furnishing written grounds of arrest.
The case concerned an accused arrested in connection with allegations of sexual offences against a minor under the Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita, 2023 and the Protection of Children from Sexual Offences Act, 2012.
The accused was arrested on May 17, 2026, but was not produced before the Magistrate until the following day. The Magistrate found that written grounds of arrest had not been furnished and directed his immediate release.
The investigating agency subsequently attempted to obtain his custody again. The accused approached the High Court seeking protection against re-arrest, but the High Court declined to grant the relief.
Before the Supreme Court, the accused challenged the legality of the subsequent proceedings, relying on violations of Article 22(1) and Article 22(2) of the Constitution.
The Supreme Court examined the earlier decisions, particularly Mihir Rajesh Shah, and clarified that the requirement of furnishing written grounds of arrest was mandatory.
The Court held that the grounds must be communicated in writing and in a language understood by the accused. A copy must be furnished as a matter of course and without exception.
It rejected the suggestion that procedural lapses in communicating the grounds of arrest could be disregarded merely because the accused could not demonstrate prejudice.
The Court also distinguished between release from illegal and unconstitutional detention and the grant of regular bail.
It held that a person released because of violation of fundamental rights is not merely being enlarged on bail. The person is being released from unconstitutional detention.
The Supreme Court accordingly set aside the High Court's order and directed that any subsequent custodial interrogation must comply with the constitutional safeguards laid down in Mihir Rajesh Shah.
This decision reinforced the mandatory approach towards written grounds of arrest.
State of Karnataka v. Sri Darshan: Prejudice-Oriented Approach
A contrasting approach was adopted in State of Karnataka v. Sri Darshan.
The Supreme Court considered whether alleged procedural defects in communicating the grounds of arrest would automatically invalidate the arrest.
The Court adopted a prejudice-oriented approach, distinguishing between failure to communicate the grounds of arrest altogether and defects in the adequacy or manner of communicating those grounds.
It held that the mere absence of written grounds would not automatically invalidate an arrest unless the defect resulted in demonstrable prejudice or deprived the accused of a fair opportunity to defend themselves.
The Court examined the circumstances surrounding the communication of the grounds, the arrest documentation and the accused's ability to understand and challenge the basis of the arrest.
This decision provided substantial support for examining actual compliance with the constitutional objective rather than treating every defect in documentation as automatically fatal.
State of Rajasthan v. Jhabra Ram: Substantial Compliance Considered Sufficient
The latest development in this line of decisions is the Supreme Court's judgment in State of Rajasthan v. Jhabra Ram, delivered on October 28, 2026.
The case concerned an accused arrested in connection with allegations of transmitting sensitive military information to Pakistani intelligence handlers.
The investigation was registered under Sections 3 and 9 of the Official Secrets Act, 1923, and Sections 152 and 238(b) of the Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita, 2023.
Before his arrest, the accused had received notices under Section 8(1) of the Official Secrets Act requiring him to provide information concerning the suspected offence.
At the time of arrest, the allegations were communicated to him and recorded in an arrest memo. The document contained details of the accusations, was read over to him and bore his signature.
His brother was also informed about the arrest.
During the remand proceedings, the accused was represented by counsel, who opposed police custody on merits without raising an objection regarding non-communication of the grounds of arrest.
The Rajasthan High Court subsequently granted him regular bail on the ground that written grounds of arrest had not been furnished before or during the remand proceedings.
The State challenged this decision before the Supreme Court.
Supreme Court's Reasoning
The Supreme Court examined whether the absence of a separately furnished written document automatically invalidated the arrest, notwithstanding the circumstances demonstrating that the accused had been informed of the allegations.
The Court relied upon the principles discussed in Kasireddy Upender Reddy and State of Karnataka v. Sri Darshan.
It observed that the constitutional requirement is intended to ensure that an arrested person understands the reasons for the arrest and is able to effectively exercise the available legal remedies.
In the present case, the Court considered several circumstances together:
1. The accused had received prior statutory notices concerning the investigation.
2. The factual allegations were communicated to him at the time of arrest.
3. The arrest memo contained details of the alleged conduct and was read over and signed by him.
4. His brother was informed about the arrest.
5. The accused was represented by a lawyer during the remand proceedings.
6. No objection concerning non-communication of the grounds of arrest was raised at that stage.
Considering these circumstances cumulatively, the Court concluded that the accused was aware of the reasons for his arrest and had been effectively represented.
It found that no demonstrable prejudice had been established because of the alleged defect in the mode of communication.
The Court held:
"the constitutional framework requires that the arrestee be informed of the grounds of arrest but does not insist upon written communication as an indispensable formality irrespective of the attendant circumstances."
It further observed:
"In the absence of demonstrable prejudice or denial of an opportunity to defend, an alleged procedural defect in the mode of service cannot ipso facto invalidate detention or entitle an accused to regular bail"
The Supreme Court consequently held that the High Court had erred in granting bail solely on the basis of the alleged procedural irregularity without considering the gravity of the allegations and the material collected during the investigation.
The appeal was allowed, the High Court's order was set aside and the regular bail granted to Jhabra Ram was cancelled.
The Court clarified that its observations were confined to the question of cancellation of bail and would not affect the determination of the allegations during trial.
Conflicting Approaches in Supreme Court Decisions
The decisions reveal two different approaches to the interpretation of Article 22(1).
The first approach treats written communication of the grounds of arrest as a mandatory constitutional requirement. Under this approach, the investigating agency must furnish the grounds in writing, in a language understood by the accused, within the prescribed timeframe. Failure to comply renders the arrest and subsequent remand unconstitutional.
This approach is reflected in Pankaj Bansal, Prabir Purkayastha, Mihir Rajesh Shah and Jaskaran Jeet Singh Deol.
The second approach focuses on whether the constitutional purpose of communicating the grounds has actually been fulfilled. Under this approach, courts examine the surrounding circumstances, the documents furnished, the accused's knowledge of the allegations, legal representation and whether the alleged procedural defect caused demonstrable prejudice.
This approach finds support in Kasireddy Upender Reddy, State of Karnataka v. Sri Darshan and the subsequent decision in State of Rajasthan v. Jhabra Ram.
An important distinction must be maintained between failure to communicate the grounds of arrest altogether and defects in the manner in which those grounds were communicated. Even the prejudice-oriented approach recognises that a complete failure to inform an arrested person cannot simply be treated as a harmless procedural irregularity.
Legal Position and Need for Further Clarification
A significant difficulty arises because Jaskaran Jeet Singh Deol and Jhabra Ram are decisions of two-judge benches of the Supreme Court, yet their reasoning reflects materially different approaches to the requirement of written communication.
Jaskaran Jeet Singh Deol, decided on September 21, 2026, expressly recognised the mandatory requirement of furnishing written grounds of arrest and endorsed Mihir Rajesh Shah as laying down the correct legal position.
Jhabra Ram, decided subsequently on October 28, 2026, held that written communication is not an indispensable formality irrespective of the circumstances and adopted a prejudice-oriented assessment.
Jhabra Ram did not expressly overrule Mihir Rajesh Shah or Jaskaran Jeet Singh Deol. Equally, it did not resolve the apparent conflict between the two approaches.
The issue therefore raises an important question concerning the extent to which a procedural defect in communicating grounds of arrest can be excused on the basis of substantial compliance.
The distinction is particularly important because Section 192(5) of the BNSS, corresponding to Section 172(3) of the Code of Criminal Procedure, restricts the ordinary right of an accused to inspect the case diary. Consequently, treating an internal police record as sufficient proof of communication may create practical difficulties when the legality of an arrest is challenged.
The burden of establishing compliance with Article 22(1), as recognised in Vihaan Kumar, also remains an important consideration.
Until the Supreme Court authoritatively clarifies the apparent divergence, the issue is likely to generate further litigation concerning the circumstances in which written grounds are indispensable and when substantial compliance may be accepted.
For investigating agencies, the safest course remains furnishing written grounds of arrest in a language understood by the arrested person, within the prescribed timeframe. This avoids unnecessary disputes concerning constitutional compliance and the legality of subsequent remand proceedings.
Case Details
Case Name: State of Rajasthan v. Jhabra Ram
Court: Supreme Court of India
Date of Decision: October 28, 2026
Case Number: Criminal Appeal No. 5092 of 2026 (arising out of SLP (Crl.) No. 13374 of 2026)
Neutral Citation: 2026 INSC 1169
Coram/Judges: Justice M.M. Sundresh and Justice Prasanna B. Varale






