Background of the Case
The Punjab and Haryana High Court has quashed criminal proceedings initiated against doctors of Dhawan Nursing Home, Bhikhiwind, who were accused of medical negligence allegedly resulting in the death of a woman following childbirth.
The case arose from a complaint filed by Gurpreet Singh, whose wife, Sandeep Kaur, experienced labour pains during the night of January 1, 2015. She was taken to Dhawan Nursing Home, where the doctors initially informed the complainant that she would undergo a normal delivery.
However, the complainant was subsequently informed that a surgical procedure was necessary. Another doctor, who was practising at Guru Nanak Dev Hospital, Amritsar, was called to perform the surgery.
Following the procedure, Sandeep Kaur delivered twin daughters. According to the complainant, he was not permitted to meet his wife after the delivery and was informed that she was suffering from excessive bleeding and that her uterus might have to be removed.
He was also asked to sign certain documents as her condition had become serious.
Allegations of Medical Negligence
The complainant alleged that his wife's condition deteriorated following the delivery and that she was subsequently shifted to another hospital for further treatment.
According to him, doctors at the second hospital informed him that the earlier surgery had not been properly performed and that the failure to remove her uterus had resulted in the spread of infection.
Despite further medical intervention, Sandeep Kaur died on January 5, 2015, during the course of treatment.
Holding the doctors responsible for her death, Gurpreet Singh initiated criminal proceedings against them.
Following the recording of preliminary evidence, the complainant examined himself and two other witnesses, including Dr. Rana Ranjit Singh, a Professor of Surgery at Sri Guru Ram Dass Institute of Medical Sciences and Research, Amritsar.
By an order dated March 23, 2018, the Judicial Magistrate First Class, Patti, found sufficient grounds to summon the doctors for offences punishable under Sections 304-A read with Section 34 of the Indian Penal Code.
Proceedings Before the High Court
Aggrieved by the summoning order, the doctors approached the Punjab and Haryana High Court by filing a petition under Section 482 of the Code of Criminal Procedure, seeking quashing of the criminal complaint and the consequential proceedings.
The petitioners contended that the Magistrate had failed to properly appreciate the medical evidence available on record.
They particularly relied upon the testimony of Dr. Rana Ranjit Singh, who had supervised the treatment of Sandeep Kaur at the subsequent hospital.
According to the petitioners, the medical evidence established that the patient had suffered from postpartum haemorrhage, followed by disseminated intravascular coagulation (DIC), which were recognised medical complications.
It was further submitted that the patient's uterus had become atonic and had subsequently been removed to save her life.
The petitioners argued that the medical evidence did not attribute any negligence to them.
Medical Board Had Found No Negligence
The doctors also brought to the Court's attention an earlier inquiry conducted pursuant to directions issued by the High Court in a separate writ petition filed by the complainant.
In that proceeding, the High Court had directed the Senior Superintendent of Police, Tarn Taran, to examine the complaint and proceed in accordance with law.
Following the directions, a team of two doctors from Civil Hospital, Tarn Taran, conducted an inquiry. The team examined the relevant circumstances, including the statement of Dr. Rana Ranjit Singh.
The inquiry report concluded that the events leading to the patient's death were natural and that no negligence or carelessness could be attributed to the doctors.
Based on the report, the police complaint had been ordered to be filed.
The petitioners further pointed out that the complainant had also initiated proceedings under the Consumer Protection Act against them, but the complaint was dismissed in default on June 14, 2024.
Relying upon the Supreme Court's decision in Jacob Mathew v. State of Punjab, the petitioners argued that a private criminal complaint alleging medical negligence could not be entertained without credible medical opinion supporting the allegations.
Supreme Court Guidelines On Criminal Prosecution Of Doctors
Justice Manisha Batra referred to the principles laid down by the Supreme Court in Jacob Mathew v. State of Punjab and another, 2005 (3) RCR (Criminal) 836.
The Supreme Court had recognised that investigating officers and private complainants cannot ordinarily be expected to possess the specialised medical knowledge necessary to determine whether a doctor's conduct amounts to criminal negligence.
It had accordingly laid down safeguards governing criminal proceedings against medical professionals.
The Supreme Court held that a private complaint alleging criminal negligence by a doctor should not ordinarily be entertained unless the complainant produces prima facie evidence in the form of a credible opinion from another competent medical professional supporting the allegation.
Similarly, before proceeding against a doctor for an allegedly rash or negligent act, the investigating officer should obtain an independent and competent medical opinion, preferably from a government doctor qualified in the relevant branch of medical practice.
The High Court also referred to Martin F. D'Souza v. Mohd. Ishfaq, 2009 (2) RCR (Criminal) 64, wherein the Supreme Court had emphasised the importance of obtaining an opinion from a competent doctor or a committee of doctors before issuing notice to a medical professional in cases alleging medical negligence.
The purpose of these safeguards is to prevent medical professionals from being unnecessarily subjected to criminal proceedings without adequate medical scrutiny.
Difference Between Civil And Criminal Medical Negligence
The High Court reiterated that every medical error, unsuccessful treatment or unfortunate medical outcome does not automatically constitute criminal negligence.
Referring to the principles in Jacob Mathew, the Court emphasised that criminal negligence requires a substantially higher degree of culpability than negligence under civil law.
A doctor cannot be held criminally liable merely because another medical professional might have adopted a different treatment method or because a better alternative was available.
The conduct must demonstrate gross negligence or recklessness of such a degree that no ordinarily prudent medical professional would have acted in that manner under the circumstances.
The Court also referred to the principles governing professional negligence, including the requirement to examine whether the doctor possessed the requisite professional skill and whether that skill was exercised with reasonable competence.
Court's Observations On The Medical Evidence
Upon examining the records, the High Court found that the Magistrate had failed to properly appreciate the medical evidence before issuing the summoning order.
The Court noted that the patient had suffered postpartum haemorrhage after delivering twin daughters. The medical inquiry conducted by a team of two doctors had concluded that there was no negligence on the part of the petitioners.
Further, Dr. Rana Ranjit Singh, who had supervised the patient's treatment at the subsequent hospital, had categorically stated in his sworn testimony that the case did not involve negligence by the petitioners.
The High Court observed that the Magistrate had merely recorded that the complainant's version was corroborated by medical evidence to the extent that the death had occurred due to pregnancy-related complications.
However, there was no finding establishing that the medical evidence demonstrated negligence by the petitioners resulting in the patient's death.
The Court found that the Magistrate had failed to appreciate that the testimony of CW-3 did not attribute any negligence to the accused doctors. On the contrary, his evidence indicated that the petitioners had not been negligent in treating the patient.
The Court further pointed out that the Magistrate had not referred the complaint to a medical board to obtain an independent and competent medical opinion, as contemplated by the Supreme Court's decisions in Jacob Mathew and Martin F. D'Souza.
In this regard, the High Court observed:
"No finding has been recorded that the medical evidence produced on record pointed out that it was a case of negligence on the part of the petitioners that resulted into death of the victim."
The Court also observed that the evidence available before the Magistrate could not be considered prima facie sufficient to substantiate the allegations of criminal negligence or rashness against the doctors.
Relevant Extract From The Judgment
While reiterating the principles governing criminal prosecution of medical professionals, the High Court reproduced the following conclusions of the Supreme Court in Jacob Mathew v. State of Punjab:
"Negligence in the context of medical profession necessarily calls for a treatment with a difference. To infer rashness or negligence on the part of a professional, in particular a doctor, additional considerations apply. A case of occupational negligence is different from one of professional negligence. A simple lack of care, an error of judgment or an accident, is not proof of negligence on the part of a medical professional."
The Supreme Court further held:
"To prosecute a medical professional for negligence under criminal law it must be shown that the accused did something or failed to do something which in the given facts and circumstances no medical professional in his ordinary senses and prudence would have done or failed to do."
These principles underline that criminal liability cannot be imposed on doctors merely because a patient suffers complications or dies during medical treatment. The prosecution must establish the requisite degree of gross negligence through appropriate medical evidence.
High Court Quashes Criminal Complaint And Summoning Order
After examining the medical evidence, the earlier inquiry report and the applicable Supreme Court guidelines, the Punjab and Haryana High Court held that there was no sufficient prima facie material to support the allegations of criminal negligence against the petitioners.
The Court found merit in the petition filed by the doctors and allowed the same.
Accordingly, the criminal complaint pending before the Judicial Magistrate First Class, Patti, the summoning order dated March 23, 2018, and all consequential proceedings arising from the complaint against the petitioners were quashed.
Case Details
Case Name: Vijay Kumar Dhawan and Others v. Gurpreet Singh
Court: Punjab and Haryana High Court
Date of Decision: January 8, 2026
Case Number: CRM-M-15772-2018 (O&M)
Neutral Citation: 2026:PHHC:000895
Coram/Judge: Justice Manisha Batra






