Background of the Case

The complaint arose from the treatment of Suresh Kumar, who was admitted to Metro Hospital, Lajpat Nagar, on 13 November 2013 with an obstruction in his artificial aortic heart valve. He was treated with streptokinase, following which he suffered a stroke affecting his speech and physical abilities.

When the hospital advised shifting him to its Noida facility for further treatment, the family alleged that the hospital failed to arrange a properly equipped ambulance and accompanying doctor. The attendants were ultimately compelled to arrange an ambulance from another hospital.

Commission's Findings

The Commission examined expert medical opinions obtained from G.B. Pant Hospital and the Delhi Medical Council. These authorities found that the treatment administered was consistent with established medical protocols and that the stroke was a recognised complication of the treatment.

Accordingly, the Commission found no medical negligence attributable to the treating doctor.

However, it separately examined the hospital's failure to arrange safe transportation. It observed that an appropriately equipped ambulance and qualified medical personnel are essential components of emergency medical care.

The hospital failed to provide a satisfactory explanation or produce evidence demonstrating that reasonable arrangements had been made for the patient's transfer.

Hospital's Liability

The Commission held that a hospital's duty of care does not end with providing treatment within its premises but also extends to ensuring reasonable patient safety during an emergency transfer to another medical facility.

It observed that providing life-support ambulance facilities and medical supervision cannot be treated as optional services.

The Commission held that the hospital's failure amounted to deficiency in service under the Consumer Protection Act, 1986.

Final Decision

The complaint was partly allowed against Metro Hospital, directing it to pay:

- ₹15 lakh as compensation for mental agony and distress.

- ₹50,000 towards litigation costs.

The amount must be paid by 6 January 2027, failing which interest at 9% per annum will apply from the date of filing of the complaint until realisation.

Case Details

Case Name: Suresh Kumar v. Metro Hospital & Heart Institute & Others

Court: Delhi State Consumer Disputes Redressal Commission

Date of Decision: 06.11.2026

Case Number: Complaint Case No. 1146/2015

Coram: Justice Sangita Dhingra Sehgal (President) and Ms. Pinki (Member, Judicial)