Statutory Authority Under the KPME Act

The Karnataka Private Medical Establishments Act provides a statutory framework for dealing with grievances and complaints concerning private medical establishments and healthcare services. The authorities constituted under the Act are expected to discharge their functions in accordance with the applicable statutory provisions and rules.

In the district-level grievance redressal mechanism, the Deputy Commissioner is designated as the Chairperson, while an officer of the District Health and Family Welfare Department functions as the Member-Secretary. The Authority is also required to function within the prescribed institutional framework.

Nature of Inquiry and Responsibility of the Authority

Proceedings involving complaints against doctors cannot be treated as informal administrative exercises. Where an authority examines allegations, considers records and arrives at decisions affecting the interests of a medical practitioner, the proceedings must satisfy the requirements of procedural fairness.

The concerned doctor must be given a reasonable opportunity to understand and respond to the allegations. This necessarily requires access to the relevant complaint, documents, records and materials relied upon during the inquiry.

Similarly, the decisions taken at different stages of the proceedings must be properly recorded. Maintenance of an accurate order sheet is essential to ensure transparency and accountability in the functioning of the Authority.

Right to Obtain Copies of Proceedings

A doctor facing an inquiry must have access to the material forming the basis of the proceedings. Copies of relevant complaints, documents, statements, charge lists, if any, and other records relied upon by the Authority should be furnished in accordance with the applicable legal provisions.

Equally important is access to the order sheet recording the proceedings and decisions taken during the inquiry. Such records enable the concerned doctor to understand the progress of the matter, identify the decisions taken and effectively exercise the right to defend against the allegations.

The refusal to provide relevant procedural records, particularly where those records are necessary to challenge or respond to adverse proceedings, may raise serious questions concerning compliance with the principles of natural justice.

Absence of Clear Procedural Rules

One of the concerns arising in the functioning of these authorities is the absence of sufficiently clear procedural guidelines governing the manner in which inquiries are to be conducted.

Where the applicable rules do not adequately prescribe the procedure for conducting inquiries, there is a possibility of inconsistent practices and excessive dependence on the individual discretion of the Chairperson.

The absence of a clearly defined procedure cannot, however, be treated as permission to conduct proceedings arbitrarily. Every statutory authority is bound to act within the limits of the legislation under which it is constituted and in accordance with established principles of fairness.

The members of the Authority must also discharge their respective statutory responsibilities rather than merely participate formally in the proceedings.

Refusal to Furnish Order Sheet in Udupi

In one instance involving proceedings before the Authority in Udupi District, an application seeking a certified copy of the order sheet was reportedly submitted on four separate occasions. However, the District Commissioner refused to furnish the requested document.

Such a refusal raises concerns regarding transparency and the procedural rights of the doctor concerned. An order sheet is not merely an internal administrative document when it records decisions and proceedings directly affecting the rights and interests of a person subjected to an inquiry.

The concerned individual must be able to seek access to such records in accordance with the applicable legal framework. A blanket refusal, without properly considering the legal entitlement to the document and the reasons for withholding it, undermines confidence in the fairness of the proceedings.

Principles of Natural Justice Must Be Followed

The principles of natural justice require that a person facing adverse proceedings should be informed of the allegations, given a reasonable opportunity to respond and afforded access to relevant materials necessary for an effective defence.

These requirements assume particular importance where complaints against medical practitioners may have consequences for their professional reputation and livelihood.

An inquiry cannot be considered fair merely because meetings are conducted and decisions are recorded. The procedure adopted must provide a meaningful opportunity to participate in the proceedings and challenge the material relied upon by the Authority.

The authorities must also ensure that their decisions are supported by relevant records and that the proceedings are conducted without arbitrariness or procedural discrimination.

Need for Legal and Administrative Accountability

The functioning of authorities constituted under the KPME Act requires greater procedural clarity and institutional accountability. The State Government should consider prescribing detailed procedural guidelines governing the conduct of inquiries, supply of documents, maintenance of order sheets and communication of decisions to the parties concerned.

It would also be desirable to ensure that the Chairperson and members are adequately familiar with the legal requirements governing quasi-judicial proceedings. Appropriate legal training or the assistance of officers possessing legal expertise would help prevent procedural irregularities and unnecessary disputes.

The State Health Minister and the Principal Secretary of the Health and Family Welfare Department should examine the concerns arising from the functioning of these authorities and take appropriate steps to ensure uniformity, transparency and adherence to the law.

Complaints against doctors must undoubtedly be examined seriously. At the same time, the existence of a complaint cannot justify arbitrary proceedings or denial of procedural safeguards. Protecting patients' interests and ensuring fairness to medical practitioners are complementary responsibilities of the statutory authorities.

A transparent and legally compliant inquiry mechanism is essential not only for protecting the rights of doctors but also for maintaining public confidence in the grievance redressal system established under the Karnataka Private Medical Establishments Act.

LEGAL POSITION – ORDER SHEET

An order sheet/proceedings sheet is the official contemporaneous record of what transpired before a Court or quasi-judicial authority.

In M.V. Kuriachan v. Shyam Prasad, 2009 Cri LJ 279, the Court held:

“What transpires in a Court on a given date are recorded by the Presiding Officer in the order sheet… [which] will normally be available to authentically reveal what transpired in court on a given date.”

In Seetharama Rao v. Karnataka Appellate Tribunal, ILR 1987 KAR 825, the Karnataka High Court held that even in pending quasi-judicial proceedings, a party cannot be denied a certified copy of the order sheet merely on the ground that the proceedings are pending.

“Every party in civil or criminal Courts is entitled to the copies of the order-sheet maintained by the Court at all stages of the case…”

In Pradeep Kumar v. Commissioner, 2020 SCC OnLine Kar 585, discrepancies between the order sheet and the final order were treated as significant in assessing procedural fairness and compliance with the principles of natural justice.

In Lajwanti v. Priti Devi, 2023 SCC OnLine HP 725, the Court emphasised the duty to maintain:

“proper order sheets of day-to-day proceedings”.

LEGAL POSITION

The authority bears the primary responsibility for properly preparing and preserving the order sheet. It constitutes an important official record of the proceedings, and the parties are entitled to access it and obtain certified copies.

By

Vivekananda Paniyala

Advocate | Paniyala & Associates

9035050005 | 9482 606060

vivekanandapaniyala@gmail.com