Background of the Case
The Karnataka High Court set aside a Family Court order directing a man and a minor child to undergo DNA testing in proceedings seeking maintenance.
The mother had filed Crl. Misc. No. 63/2025 before the Family Court, Bengaluru, seeking maintenance for her minor child. During the proceedings, she filed an application under Section 45 of the Bharatiya Sakshya Adhiniyam, 2023, seeking a DNA test to establish the child's biological relationship with the man.
The Family Court allowed the application on 18 March 2026, relying on circumstances including the man's admission of a physical relationship with the mother, his interactions with the child and his financial contributions.
High Court's Observations
Justice Lalitha Kanneganti observed that an admission of a physical relationship is relevant but does not conclusively establish paternity. The relationship between two individuals, by itself, cannot prove that the man fathered the child.
The Court clarified that children born within or outside marriage are entitled to maintenance under Section 144(1)(b) of the Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita, 2023. However, the liability of the person from whom maintenance is claimed must be established through evidence.
The Court also explained that rejection of an earlier application for DNA testing does not automatically amount to a final determination of paternity. The principle of res judicata would apply where paternity itself has been conclusively decided.
Referring to Section 112 of the Indian Evidence Act and the Supreme Court's decision in Ivan Rathinam v. Milan Joseph, the Court emphasised that the statutory presumption of legitimacy, wherever applicable, must be considered before directing DNA testing.
Right to Privacy and Proportionality
The Court observed that DNA testing involves the collection of biological material and may reveal sensitive genetic information, thereby affecting the individual's right to privacy and bodily autonomy under Article 21 of the Constitution.
Referring to the principles laid down in Justice K.S. Puttaswamy v. Union of India, the Court held that such interference must satisfy the requirements of legitimacy, necessity and proportionality.
The Court observed:
"The child's need for maintenance establishes the importance of deciding the claim expeditiously. It does not necessarily establish that the claim is decided only through scientific testing."
Final Decision
The High Court held that the Family Court had failed to examine whether paternity could be established through other available evidence and whether DNA testing was genuinely necessary.
Accordingly, it set aside the DNA testing order and remanded the matter to the Family Court for fresh consideration. The Family Court was directed to examine the earlier civil proceedings, applicability of the statutory presumption of legitimacy and available evidence.
If DNA testing is considered necessary, the Family Court must record reasons establishing that the dispute cannot be resolved through other evidence and that the examination is proportionate.
Case Details
Case Name: Mr. Filix Miller and Felix Miller v. Ms. Nandakumari
Court: Karnataka High Court, Bengaluru
Date of Decision: 3 November 2026
Case Number: Writ Petition No. 11719 of 2026 (GM-FC)
Coram/Judge: Justice Lalitha Kanneganti






