Background of the Case
The Madras High Court was hearing a writ petition filed by M. Sangeetha seeking action against a doctor for alleged medical negligence during her Caesarean section and tubectomy performed on September 4, 2010, at Corporation Maternity Hospital, Ayanavaram, Chennai.
The petitioner claimed that she continued to experience severe abdominal pain, menstrual bleeding and physical discomfort after the surgery. Despite receiving treatment at different hospitals, her condition did not improve.
On January 3, 2022, she approached Kilpauk Government Hospital with severe abdominal pain and vomiting. Scanning and X-ray examinations revealed a surgical needle measuring approximately 5 cm inside her abdomen. She subsequently underwent another surgery between January 3 and 12, 2022, to remove the needle.
She alleged that the needle had been left behind during the earlier surgery and sought action against the doctor concerned.
Court's Observations
The respondents opposed the petition, arguing that the petitioner had approached the Court after a delay of 12 years.
However, Justice P.T. Asha observed that the petitioner belonged to an economically weaker section and that her husband was a daily-wage labourer. The Court noted that her financial circumstances had prevented her from obtaining medical treatment earlier.
The Court also considered the medical records of Kilpauk Government Hospital, which recorded the presence of the needle and showed that the petitioner had not undergone any other surgery apart from the procedure performed at the respondent hospital.
The Court observed:
"This finding clearly exposes the callous manner in which the surgery was performed. This incident definitely requires an investigation."
It further held that the alleged negligence and the suffering endured by the petitioner could not be overlooked merely because she had approached the Court belatedly.
Court's Decision
The Madras High Court suo motu impleaded the Tamil Nadu Medical Council as a respondent and directed it to issue notice to the doctor concerned and the petitioner.
The Council was directed to consider the medical records relating to the petitioner's delivery and the report of Kilpauk Medical College Hospital, hear both parties and pass appropriate orders on her representation.
The entire exercise was directed to be completed within two months from the date of receipt of a copy of the order.
Case Details
Case Name: M. Sangeetha v. The State & Others
Court: Madras High Court
Date of Decision: 5 November 2026
Case Number: W.P. No. 28856 of 2023
Coram/Judge: Justice P.T. Asha






