Background of the Case
The Delhi High Court has quashed criminal proceedings against Venkateshwar Hospital and its Senior Consultant Obstetrician and Gynaecologist, Dr. Dipti K. Yadav, arising out of an incident in which a cotton mop was inadvertently left inside a woman's abdomen during a Lower Segment Caesarean Section (LSCS).
The patient, Smt. Tamanna, had been receiving pregnancy-related treatment at Venkateshwar Hospital, located in Sector 18A, Dwarka, New Delhi, under the supervision of Dr. Dipti K. Yadav.
On January 12, 2021, she underwent a C-section procedure at the hospital. During the surgery, an abdominal cotton mop was allegedly left inside her abdominal cavity.
The retained foreign object subsequently resulted in a severe infection and pus collection. The patient was eventually required to undergo another major surgical procedure at Indraprastha Apollo Hospital to remove the retained mop.
Following the incident, the patient lodged a complaint alleging medical negligence against the hospital and the gynaecologist.
Registration of FIR
Based on the patient's complaint, FIR No. 455/2022 dated July 14, 2022, was registered at Dwarka North Police Station against the hospital and the doctor.
The FIR invoked Sections 336, 337 and 34 of the Indian Penal Code, 1860, relating to acts endangering life or personal safety and causing hurt through rash or negligent conduct.
The allegations concerned the failure to ensure that all surgical materials had been removed before the completion of the C-section procedure.
Disciplinary Proceedings Before the Delhi Medical Council
The incident was also examined by the Disciplinary Committee of the Delhi Medical Council, which passed an order dated April 27, 2022.
The Committee observed that the abdominal mop subsequently recovered during the laparotomy procedure at Indraprastha Apollo Hospital was, in all likelihood, the same mop that had been left inside the patient's abdomen during the C-section performed at Venkateshwar Hospital.
Although the hospital's surgical safety checklist indicated that the mop count had been correctly recorded at the beginning and conclusion of the operation, the recovery of the foreign object established that an error had occurred in the counting process.
The Committee, however, found that the hospital and doctor had followed the appropriate management protocol during the post-operative period and had made a timely surgical referral.
It also noted that surgical advice had been followed and the patient's condition had started improving.
At the same time, the Committee questioned why a CT scan had not been conducted at Venkateshwar Hospital despite being advised, observing that the investigation could probably have detected the retained mop and enabled earlier corrective surgery.
The Committee concluded that Dr. Dipti K. Yadav had failed to exercise the degree of diligence expected from an ordinarily prudent medical practitioner.
Consequently, it recommended that her name be removed from the State Medical Register maintained by the Delhi Medical Council for a period of 30 days.
However, the Committee specifically observed that the doctor's acts or omissions were not reckless or patently wanton so as to attract criminal liability.
It also recommended disciplinary action against the scrub nurse, Ms. Menika Singh, who was responsible for counting the surgical instruments and mops used during the procedure.
Delhi Medical Council Holds Mop Counting to Be a Shared Responsibility
The findings of the Disciplinary Committee were subsequently considered by the Delhi Medical Council.
By an order dated May 10, 2022, the Council confirmed the Committee's findings and directed that an additional observation be incorporated into the order.
The Council specifically clarified that the responsibility for counting surgical mops was shared between the operating surgeon and the staff nurse.
This observation was relevant because the retained mop resulted from an error in the surgical counting process, which was not the responsibility of the doctor alone.
Settlement Between the Parties
During the pendency of the criminal proceedings, the hospital, the doctor and the patient amicably resolved their dispute through the Mediation Centre, Dwarka Courts, New Delhi.
A settlement agreement was executed on August 6, 2025.
Under the settlement, the patient received compensation of Rs.14 lakh.
The patient subsequently informed the Delhi High Court that the settlement had been entered into voluntarily, without coercion, pressure or undue influence.
She also confirmed that she was satisfied with the compensation received and did not wish to pursue further proceedings arising out of the FIR.
An affidavit recording her no-objection to quashing the criminal proceedings and proof of payment of the settlement amount were also placed before the Court.
Petition Before the Delhi High Court
Following the settlement, Venkateshwar Hospital and Dr. Dipti K. Yadav approached the Delhi High Court seeking quashing of FIR No.455/2022 and all consequential proceedings.
The petition was filed under Article 226 of the Constitution of India read with Section 528 of the Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita, 2023 (BNSS).
The petitioners relied upon the amicable settlement, the medical findings recorded by the Delhi Medical Council and the patient's decision not to pursue the criminal proceedings.
The Court also recorded that the chargesheet had already been filed.
Legal Position on Quashing Criminal Proceedings Following Settlement
Justice Amit Mahajan examined the principles governing the High Court's power to quash criminal proceedings where the parties have settled their dispute.
The Court referred to the Supreme Court's decision in Narinder Singh & Ors. v. State of Punjab & Anr. (2014) 6 SCC 466.
The Supreme Court had clarified that the inherent jurisdiction of the High Court to quash criminal proceedings is distinct from its statutory power to permit compounding of offences under Section 320 of the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973.
Consequently, even offences that are not compoundable can be quashed in appropriate cases where the parties have settled their dispute.
However, such power must be exercised cautiously, having regard to the nature and gravity of the offence, the interests of justice and the possibility of conviction.
The Delhi High Court also referred to Parbatbhai Aahir & Ors. v. State of Gujarat & Anr. (2017) 9 SCC 641, wherein the Supreme Court reiterated that the power to quash proceedings following a settlement is intended to prevent abuse of the process of law and secure the ends of justice.
The Court noted that the power cannot ordinarily be exercised in cases involving heinous offences or serious crimes having a substantial impact on society merely because the victim and accused have reached a settlement.
Criminal Liability of Doctors Requires Gross Negligence
The Court examined the legal distinction between ordinary medical negligence and criminal medical negligence.
It relied upon the Supreme Court's decision in Jacob Mathew v. State of Punjab (2005) 6 SCC 1, which laid down safeguards governing the prosecution of medical practitioners for criminal negligence.
The Supreme Court had emphasised that before proceeding against a doctor for criminal negligence, the investigating agency should obtain an independent and competent medical opinion, preferably from a government doctor qualified in the relevant branch of medicine.
The Court also referred to Suresh Gupta v. Government of NCT of Delhi & Ors. (2004) 6 SCC 422, in which the Supreme Court explained that criminal liability cannot be imposed upon a medical practitioner merely because an error or omission occurred during treatment.
For criminal liability to arise, the negligence must be of such a serious degree that it can be characterised as gross negligence or recklessness.
The mere absence of adequate care or an inadvertent mistake may give rise to civil liability, but does not automatically establish a criminal offence.
Court's Findings on the Medical Negligence Allegations
Applying these principles, the Delhi High Court examined the medical findings recorded by the Disciplinary Committee of the Delhi Medical Council and subsequently confirmed by the Council.
The Court observed that the medical opinion obtained in the present case established that the hospital and doctor had followed the appropriate post-operative management protocol and had made a timely surgical referral.
The surgical advice was also properly followed, and the patient's condition had started improving.
However, the recovery of the abdominal mop during the subsequent surgery indicated that there had been an error in counting the surgical mops during the original C-section procedure.
The Court took note of the medical finding that counting surgical mops was a shared responsibility of the operating surgeon and the staff nurse.
Although Dr. Dipti K. Yadav had failed to exercise the due diligence expected from an ordinarily prudent doctor, the medical authorities had specifically concluded that her conduct did not amount to reckless or patently wanton behaviour warranting criminal prosecution.
The Court further noted that the findings of the Disciplinary Committee had been confirmed by the Delhi Medical Board.
It therefore found no evidence of gross incompetence or recklessness on the part of the petitioners sufficient to justify continuation of the criminal proceedings.
Court's Observations on the Retained Surgical Mop
While considering the consequences of the incident, the Court acknowledged the serious discomfort and suffering experienced by the patient due to the inadvertent retention of a foreign object inside her abdomen.
Justice Amit Mahajan observed:
"This Court is fully cognizant of the discomfort suffered by the patient due to the inadvertent retention of a foreign object in her abdomen, which is unquestionably a matter of profound concern and merits unequivocal censure, as medical professionals are entrusted with the exacting duty of care.
Nevertheless, the record, specifically the medical opinion obtained, reveals that the incident was unintentional and due oversight, bereft of the necessary mens rea and such degree of rashness to attract the rigours of a criminal trial."
The Court thus distinguished the serious consequences of the surgical lapse from the degree of negligence necessary to establish criminal liability.
Compensation and Disciplinary Action Considered by the Court
The Court also considered the fact that the patient had already received compensation of Rs.14 lakh under the settlement agreement and had expressly stated that she did not wish to pursue the criminal proceedings.
It further took note of the disciplinary consequences already imposed upon the medical personnel involved.
Dr. Dipti K. Yadav's name had been removed from the State Medical Register for 30 days, while disciplinary action had been recommended against the nurse responsible for counting the surgical mops.
Considering these circumstances together, the Court observed that the allegations, at best, could give rise to civil liability.
It held that continuing the criminal proceedings despite the medical findings, disciplinary action and voluntary settlement would cause unnecessary harassment to the parties and amount to an abuse of the process of the Court.
Final Decision of the Delhi High Court
The Delhi High Court held that the case was appropriate for exercising its discretionary jurisdiction under Section 528 of the BNSS.
Accordingly, the Court quashed FIR No.455/2022 and all consequential proceedings arising from it.
However, taking into consideration that the State machinery had already been set in motion and the chargesheet had been filed, the Court imposed a total cost of Rs.25,000 on the hospital and the doctor.
The amount was directed to be deposited with the Delhi Police Martyrs' Fund within four weeks.
The petition was allowed in these terms, and the pending applications were also disposed of.
Legal Significance of the Decision
The judgment reiterates the distinction between civil and criminal liability in cases involving medical negligence.
An inadvertent surgical error, even one resulting in serious physical consequences for a patient, does not automatically establish criminal negligence on the part of the treating doctor.
For criminal prosecution, the conduct must satisfy the higher threshold of gross negligence or recklessness recognised by the Supreme Court.
The decision also highlights the importance of obtaining competent medical opinion before initiating criminal proceedings against medical practitioners.
At the same time, the judgment does not absolve hospitals or doctors of their professional responsibilities merely because an incident was unintentional. Civil liability and disciplinary consequences may continue to arise even where the conduct does not satisfy the requirements for criminal prosecution.
Importantly, the FIR was quashed after considering the particular medical findings, disciplinary action, compensation already paid and the patient's voluntary decision not to pursue the proceedings. The decision should not be understood as laying down that every case involving a retained surgical instrument can be terminated merely on the basis of a settlement.
Case Details
Case Name: Venkateshwar Hospital and Anr. v. State of NCT Delhi and Anr.
Court: High Court of Delhi
Date of Decision: December 2, 2025
Case Number: W.P.(CRL) 3976/2025 & CRL.M.A. 35803/2025, CRL.M.A. 35804/2025
Coram/Judge: Justice Amit Mahajan
Citation: 2025 LiveLaw (Del) 1702






