Background of the Case
The Delhi High Court has quashed an FIR registered against Venkateshwar Hospital and Dr. Dipti K. Yadav, a senior consultant gynaecologist, over allegations of medical negligence arising from the retention of a surgical cotton mop inside a woman's abdomen during a caesarean section.
The complainant, Tamanna, was receiving pregnancy-related treatment at Venkateshwar Hospital under the supervision of Dr. Yadav.
On January 12, 2021, the doctor performed a Lower Segment Caesarean Section (LSCS) on the patient. However, an abdominal cotton mop was allegedly left inside her abdominal cavity during the procedure.
The retained surgical material subsequently resulted in an infection and collection of pus. The patient was eventually required to undergo another major surgery at Indraprastha Apollo Hospital to remove the foreign object.
Following the incident, the patient lodged a complaint alleging medical negligence against the hospital and the treating gynaecologist.
Registration of FIR and Medical Council Proceedings
Based on the complaint, FIR No. 455/2022 was registered on July 14, 2022, at Dwarka North Police Station for offences punishable under Sections 336, 337 and 34 of the Indian Penal Code, 1860.
The allegations were also examined by the Disciplinary Committee of the Delhi Medical Council.
In its order dated April 27, 2022, the Disciplinary Committee observed that the abdominal mop recovered during the subsequent surgery at Indraprastha Apollo Hospital was, in all likelihood, the same mop that had been left behind during the caesarean procedure at Venkateshwar Hospital.
Although the hospital's surgical safety checklist indicated that the surgical equipment had been counted before and after the operation, the recovery of the mop suggested an error in the counting process.
The Committee also examined the post-operative treatment provided to the patient. It found that appropriate management protocols had been followed and that a timely surgical referral had been made.
However, the Committee observed that a CT scan had not been conducted at Venkateshwar Hospital despite being advised, which could potentially have helped identify the retained mop and facilitated earlier corrective surgery.
The Committee concluded that Dr. Yadav had failed to exercise the degree of diligence expected from an ordinarily prudent medical practitioner. Consequently, it recommended removal of her name from the State Medical Register for a period of 30 days.
At the same time, the Committee specifically observed that the doctor's acts or omissions were not reckless or patently wanton so as to attract criminal liability.
The Committee also recommended disciplinary action against the scrub nurse, Menika Singh, who was responsible for counting the surgical instruments and mops used during the procedure.
The Delhi Medical Council subsequently confirmed the Committee's findings through an order dated May 10, 2022. It additionally clarified that counting surgical mops was a shared responsibility of the operating surgeon and the nursing staff.
Settlement Between the Patient and Hospital
During the pendency of the criminal proceedings, the parties resolved their disputes through mediation at the Mediation Centre, Dwarka Courts, New Delhi.
A settlement agreement was executed on August 6, 2025.
The hospital and the doctor subsequently approached the Delhi High Court seeking quashing of the FIR and the consequential criminal proceedings on the ground that the dispute had been amicably settled.
During the hearing, the complainant appeared before the Court through video conferencing, while the doctor was personally present.
The complainant informed the Court that she had voluntarily entered into the settlement without any coercion, pressure or undue influence. She also confirmed that she had received compensation of Rs. 14 lakh and did not wish to pursue further proceedings arising out of the FIR.
She expressed her willingness to have the criminal proceedings quashed, stating that their continuation would result in further harassment of the parties.
Her no-objection affidavit and the receipt evidencing payment of the settlement amount were also placed before the Court.
Legal Issue Before the Court
The principal question before the Delhi High Court was whether criminal proceedings alleging medical negligence could be quashed in exercise of its inherent jurisdiction under Section 528 of the Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita, 2023, particularly when the dispute had been settled and the available medical opinion did not indicate criminally reckless conduct.
The Court also examined the distinction between ordinary medical negligence, which may give rise to civil liability or disciplinary action, and gross negligence or recklessness capable of attracting criminal prosecution.
Court's Observations on Quashing Criminal Proceedings After Settlement
Justice Amit Mahajan observed that the High Court possesses the power to quash criminal proceedings involving non-compoundable offences when the circumstances justify such intervention, notwithstanding the restrictions governing compounding under Section 320 of the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973.
The Court relied upon the Supreme Court's decision in Narinder Singh v. State of Punjab, (2014) 6 SCC 466, which laid down the principles governing the exercise of inherent jurisdiction when parties seek quashing of criminal proceedings on the basis of a settlement.
The Supreme Court had clarified that such powers must be exercised cautiously, keeping in view the nature and gravity of the offence, the possibility of conviction and whether continuation of the proceedings would serve the ends of justice.
The High Court also referred to Parbatbhai Aahir v. State of Gujarat, (2017) 9 SCC 641, wherein the Supreme Court explained that the power to quash criminal proceedings is distinct from the statutory power to compound offences.
The Court emphasised that the nature of the allegations, their impact on society and the circumstances surrounding the settlement must be considered before exercising such jurisdiction.
Criminal Liability Requires Gross Negligence or Recklessness
The Court examined the principles laid down by the Supreme Court in Jacob Mathew v. State of Punjab, (2005) 6 SCC 1, concerning criminal prosecution of medical practitioners.
In that decision, the Supreme Court had laid down safeguards against the routine initiation of criminal proceedings against doctors for alleged negligence. It emphasised the importance of obtaining an independent and competent medical opinion before proceeding against a medical practitioner for criminal negligence.
The Delhi High Court also relied upon Suresh Gupta v. Government of NCT of Delhi, (2004) 6 SCC 422, wherein the Supreme Court distinguished ordinary negligence from the degree of negligence required to establish criminal liability.
The legal position emerging from these decisions is that every error or instance of inadequate care during medical treatment does not automatically constitute a criminal offence. Criminal liability requires a substantially higher degree of negligence, involving gross disregard for the patient's safety or reckless conduct.
Court's Assessment of the Medical Evidence
Applying these principles to the facts, the High Court considered the findings recorded by the Delhi Medical Council.
The Court noted that the medical opinion had acknowledged an error in the counting of surgical mops during the caesarean procedure. Such counting was a shared responsibility of the operating surgeon and the nursing staff.
However, the medical authorities had also recorded that the post-operative management was appropriate, a timely surgical referral was made and the patient's condition had started improving after the necessary medical advice was followed.
The Court further took note of the disciplinary action recommended against the gynaecologist and the nursing staff.
Justice Mahajan observed that although Dr. Yadav had not exercised the due diligence expected from an ordinarily prudent doctor, the medical authorities had not found her conduct to be reckless or patently wanton.
The Court therefore concluded that the material on record did not disclose the degree of gross negligence or recklessness necessary to justify criminal prosecution.
Court's Findings on Criminal and Civil Liability
The High Court expressly acknowledged the seriousness of leaving a foreign object inside a patient's abdomen during surgery.
It observed that medical professionals are entrusted with an exacting duty of care and that the patient's suffering on account of the incident deserved unequivocal censure.
However, the Court distinguished the existence of a medical lapse from the requirements for imposing criminal liability.
The Court observed:
"This Court is fully cognizant of the discomfort suffered by the patient due to the inadvertent retention of a foreign object in her abdomen, which is unquestionably a matter of profound concern and merits unequivocal censure, as medical professionals are entrusted with the exacting duty of care.
Nevertheless, the record, specifically the medical opinion obtained, reveals that the incident was unintentional and due oversight, bereft of the necessary mens rea and such degree of rashness to attract the rigours of a criminal trial."
The Court further observed:
"At the best the facts could have delineated a civil liability, however, considering that the name of the Petitioner No. 2 was removed from State Medical Register of Delhi Medical Council for a period of 30 days, disciplinary action being directed to be taken against the nurse who incorrectly counted the no. of mops, the matter has been amicably settled between the parties and the compensation amount of ₹14,00,000/- has already been received by the Complainant, continuance of the proceedings will only cause undue harassment to all the parties and will be an abuse of the process of the Court."
The Court thus found that the combination of the medical opinion, disciplinary action, voluntary settlement and payment of compensation justified quashing the criminal proceedings.
Final Decision
Justice Amit Mahajan held that the case was appropriate for exercising the High Court's jurisdiction under Section 528 of the BNSS, 2023.
Taking into consideration that the police machinery had already been set in motion and a chargesheet had been filed, the Court directed the hospital and the doctor to pay costs of Rs. 25,000.
The amount was directed to be deposited with the Delhi Police Martyrs' Fund within four weeks, with proof of deposit to be submitted to the concerned Station House Officer.
Accordingly, the Delhi High Court quashed FIR No. 455/2022 and all consequential proceedings arising from it, subject to payment of the specified costs.
The writ petition was allowed and the pending application was also disposed of.
Case Details
Case Name: Venkateshwar Hospital and Anr. v. State of NCT Delhi and Anr.
Court: Delhi High Court
Date of Decision: December 2, 2025
Case Number: W.P. (CRL) 3976/2025 along with CRL.M.A. 35803/2025 and CRL.M.A. 35804/2025
Coram/Judge: Justice Amit Mahajan






