Background of the Case

The Karnataka High Court, Dharwad Bench, has held that an alleged examination violation in a cancelled examination cannot, without sufficient legal justification, be used to deny a candidate the benefits of merit independently established in a subsequent examination.

The petitioner, Anushka Basavaraj Maidur, appeared for NEET (UG) 2026 conducted on May 3, 2026. Following widespread allegations of question paper leakage, the National Testing Agency (NTA) cancelled the examination and announced a fresh examination for June 21, 2026.

The petitioner received a fresh admit card and appeared for the re-examination. However, on June 17, 2026, the NTA issued her a show-cause notice alleging that she had carried a mobile phone into the examination premises during the earlier examination.

The petitioner explained that the phone had inadvertently remained in her pocket and had not been used. Subsequently, the Unfair Means Committee decided to withhold her re-examination result. She had secured 570 marks, but her scorecard dated July 16, 2026, carried the remark 'Result Withheld'.

Arguments of the Parties

The petitioner contended that an alleged violation relating to an examination that had been completely cancelled could not be used to invalidate her performance in an independent re-examination. She also argued that mere possession of a mobile phone, without establishing an attempt to secure an unfair advantage, could not justify such severe consequences.

The NTA maintained that carrying a mobile phone was expressly prohibited under the examination rules and that withholding the result was the least penalty prescribed for unfair means.

Court's Observations

A Division Bench comprising Justice M. Nagaprasanna and Justice Hema Kulkarni observed that the earlier examination had lost its legal and academic significance following its cancellation. The petitioner had received no academic advantage from that examination and had subsequently secured her medical seat through a fresh examination in which no malpractice was alleged.

The Court distinguished between a breach of examination discipline and actually securing academic merit through dishonest means. It observed that mere possession of a prohibited device could not invariably be equated with the use of unfair means, without considering the surrounding circumstances.

The Bench further held that examination rules must protect fairness and merit rather than become instruments of disproportionate punishment.

The Court made the following significant observation:

"The examination in which the alleged infraction occurred was itself scrapped. Its results were rendered inconsequential. No academic advantage flowing from that examination has been carried forward to the benefit of the petitioner. The petitioner thereafter appeared in a fresh examination, competed with other aspirants and emerged with high merit. No allegation of malpractice in the subsequent examination is placed against her. Therefore, the examination that was scrapped cannot be resurrected merely to eclipse the merit earned in the examination that survived."

Final Decision

Allowing the writ petition, the High Court quashed the show-cause notice dated June 17, 2026, and the scorecard remark withholding the petitioner's result.

The Court sustained her medical seat at Belagavi Institute of Medical Sciences and directed the NTA to issue her scorecard without any remark indicating that her result was withheld or cancelled.

Case Details

Case Name: Anushka Basavaraj Maidur v. National Testing Agency & Ors.

Court: Karnataka High Court, Dharwad Bench

Date of Decision: November 19, 2026

Case Number: Writ Petition No. 107041 of 2026 (EDN-EX)

Coram/Judges: Justice M. Nagaprasanna and Justice Hema Kulkarni