Background of the Cases

The Kerala High Court considered two connected criminal miscellaneous petitions filed by medical practitioners facing prosecution under Section 304A of the Indian Penal Code (IPC) for allegedly causing the death of patients through medical negligence.

The common issue raised in both petitions concerned the functioning of medical Expert Panels constituted to examine allegations of negligence against doctors. The petitioners contended that the Expert Panels had given adverse opinions against them without providing an opportunity to explain their treatment decisions or furnishing copies of the reports.

The Court examined whether the existing procedures followed by the Kerala Government adequately protected the rights of medical practitioners while ensuring an impartial investigation into allegations of medical negligence.

First Case: Alleged Negligence in Treating a Patient with Chest Injury

In the first case, the petitioner, Dr. Mohamed Rizwan T., was the sole accused in a criminal case registered following the death of a patient, Vinod P.V., who had been admitted to Amala Medical College on July 12, 2023, with a chest injury.

The patient was initially taken to a Government Hospital and subsequently referred to other hospitals before being admitted to Amala Medical College. He died during treatment on July 14, 2023.

Following the patient's death, a post-mortem examination revealed a collection of blood in the chest cavity and collapse of the underlying lung. The forensic opinion subsequently raised concerns regarding the treatment provided.

The District Medical Board, in its meeting held on February 19, 2024, reportedly found negligence in the treatment administered at the hospital. It observed that despite a scan indicating substantial blood accumulation and a radiologist identifying the area for tube insertion, there had been no immediate consultation with a cardiothoracic surgeon or drainage procedure.

Based on the Expert Panel's report, the police registered a case against the petitioner on June 28, 2024, under Section 304A IPC. A final report was subsequently filed before the jurisdictional Magistrate.

The doctor challenged the Expert Panel's findings, contending that the committee had failed to consider the patient's alcohol withdrawal-induced delirium and aggressive behaviour, which allegedly made the insertion of a chest tube medically risky.

He argued that the patient's vital parameters had remained stable and that the decision to manage the condition without immediate tube insertion was consistent with an acceptable medical approach.

The petitioner further submitted that he could have explained the medical reasons behind the treatment adopted had the Expert Panel provided him an opportunity of hearing. He also complained that the report had not been furnished to him.

Second Case: Alleged Negligence Following Caesarean Delivery

The second petition concerned a gynaecologist facing prosecution following the death of a woman, Bindu Sajeev, after a caesarean delivery performed on July 26, 2010, at Chitra Multispeciality Hospital, Pandalam.

During the procedure, the patient was found to have a large retroperitoneal haematoma extending from the diaphragm to the pelvic wall. The hospital adopted conservative treatment after consulting its surgeon.

As her condition deteriorated, the patient's husband was advised to shift her to the Kottayam Medical College Hospital, a higher medical centre. The advice was reportedly given around midnight and repeated at approximately 4:10 a.m. on July 27, 2010. However, the patient was taken to the hospital only around 6 a.m. and died before reaching it.

The Expert Panel constituted to examine the incident initially observed that it could not identify any act of commission by the treating doctor. However, it subsequently opined that an earlier referral and timely exploratory surgery could have saved the patient's life, attributing negligence to the doctor on that basis.

The doctor challenged the report, arguing that he had repeatedly advised the patient's relatives to shift her to a higher medical centre and that the delay in transferring her could not automatically be attributed to him.

He also contended that the Expert Panel had failed to provide him with an opportunity to explain his position or furnish a copy of its findings. An appeal against the report was pending before the State Level Apex Expert Committee.

Submissions Before the High Court

The petitioners primarily questioned the manner in which the Expert Panels were constituted and their reports prepared.

They argued that an expert opinion could have serious consequences for a medical practitioner, particularly when it formed the basis for criminal prosecution. Therefore, doctors should be allowed to explain their treatment decisions before an adverse opinion was finalised.

They also highlighted the difficulty in challenging an Expert Panel's findings when the report itself was not furnished to the concerned doctor.

The Additional Director General of Prosecution (ADGP), appearing for the State, acknowledged that doctors should ideally be given an opportunity to explain their actions before the Expert Panel reached its conclusions.

The ADGP further suggested that copies of the reports should be provided to the concerned doctors and that investigations should take into account the outcome of any appeal filed against the Expert Panel's findings before the final report was submitted to the court.

Advocate Akash S. was appointed as amicus curiae to assist the High Court in formulating appropriate guidelines. The Court also considered submissions made by representatives of the medical profession and the Medico-Legal Society of India.

Supreme Court's Principles on Criminal Medical Negligence

Justice V.G. Arun examined the principles governing medical negligence laid down by the Supreme Court, particularly in Dr. Suresh Gupta v. Government of NCT of Delhi and Jacob Mathew v. State of Punjab.

The Court reiterated the distinction between civil and criminal medical negligence.

While an ordinary failure to exercise reasonable care may, depending on the circumstances, give rise to civil liability, criminal prosecution requires a substantially higher degree of negligence. Mere errors of judgment, inadvertence or the existence of an alternative treatment method do not automatically establish criminal negligence.

In Jacob Mathew v. State of Punjab, the Supreme Court had explained that criminal liability against a medical practitioner requires negligence of a gross or very high degree.

The High Court also referred to the Bolam test, which requires the conduct of a medical practitioner to be assessed against the standard of an ordinarily competent professional possessing the relevant medical skill.

A doctor cannot be held negligent merely because another practitioner might have adopted a different treatment method, provided the course followed was consistent with a practice accepted by a responsible body of medical professionals.

Importance of the Right to Preliminary Hearing

The High Court examined the existing circulars issued by the Kerala Government governing investigations into allegations of medical negligence and the constitution of Expert Panels and Apex Committees.

The Court observed that although the Government had issued several circulars since 1989 dealing with the investigation process and constitution of expert bodies, those instructions did not specifically provide for an opportunity of hearing to the medical practitioner against whom negligence was alleged.

The Court also referred to the position adopted by the Government of Karnataka.

It noted that Karnataka, through Standing Order No.1018 concerning the Standard Operating Procedure (SoP) for dealing with violence against medical professionals and medical establishments, had made it mandatory for the expert body to allow the concerned doctor to submit a written explanation and provide a personal hearing if requested.

The High Court considered this an important procedural safeguard that could also be incorporated into Kerala's framework.

The Court further examined recommendations made by the Ethics and Medical Registration Board of the National Medical Commission, which contemplated a structured system involving District and State Medical Boards, specialist participation, time-bound examination of complaints and safeguards against arbitrary arrest of medical practitioners.

Reference to Lalita Kumari v. Government of Uttar Pradesh

The High Court also referred to the Constitution Bench decision in Lalita Kumari v. Government of Uttar Pradesh, which recognised that medical negligence cases are among the categories in which a preliminary inquiry may be conducted, depending on the facts and circumstances, before registration of an FIR.

The relevant portion of paragraph 120.6 of the Supreme Court's decision reads:

"120.6. As to what type and in which cases preliminary inquiry is to be conducted will depend on the facts and circumstances of each case. The category of cases in which preliminary inquiry may be made are as under:

(a) Matrimonial disputes/family disputes

(b) Commercial offences

(c) Medical negligence cases

(d) Corruption cases

(e) Cases where there is abnormal delay/laches in initiating criminal prosecution, for example, over 3 months' delay in reporting the matter without satisfactorily explaining the reasons for delay.

The aforesaid are only illustrations and not exhaustive of all conditions which may warrant preliminary inquiry."

The High Court considered these principles alongside the existing State circulars and the need to ensure that investigations into medical negligence allegations are conducted fairly.

12-Point Draft Guidelines Proposed by the High Court

After examining the relevant judgments, government circulars and submissions of the parties, the High Court concluded that the Kerala Government should formulate comprehensive guidelines governing the constitution and functioning of Expert Panels and the State Level Apex Committee.

The Court accordingly proposed the following 12-point draft framework for the Government's consideration:

1. Collection of Medical Records: Upon receiving a complaint alleging medical negligence, the Investigating Officer should promptly secure relevant medical documents, including doctors' notes, nurses' diaries, duty rosters, shift reports, attendance sheets, assessment forms, consent forms, medical and diagnostic reports, laboratory results, referral records, treatment notes and discharge summaries.

2. Constitution of Expert Panel: The Investigating Officer should immediately inform the concerned authority about the complaint and request the constitution of an Expert Panel.

3. Specialist Representation: Each district should maintain a speciality-wise list of medical practitioners familiar with the procedure for examining medical negligence complaints. Every Expert Panel should include a doctor from the relevant medical speciality.

4. Time Limit for Proceedings: The Expert Panel should complete its proceedings within 30 days from the date of its constitution.

5. Written Representations: Both the medical practitioner concerned and the complainant should receive notice and be permitted to submit written representations before the Expert Panel.

6. Personal Hearing: Where the Expert Panel finds prima facie material indicating gross negligence, the concerned medical practitioner should be called upon to appear personally and explain the procedure adopted or treatment provided.

7. Individual Opinions of Experts: The Expert Panel's report should record the individual opinion of every member. Its final conclusion should be based on consensus.

8. Identification of Responsible Practitioners: The report should specifically examine whether gross negligence or recklessness resulting in loss of life can be attributed to the medical practitioner. Where multiple doctors are involved, it should identify the individual practitioners responsible and provide reasons for reaching that conclusion.

9. Application of Bolam Test: The Expert Panel should consistently apply the Bolam test while examining criminal medical negligence. Its reasoning should be expressly recorded in the report. A standard reporting template may also be developed for uniformity.

10. Supply of Expert Panel Report: A copy of the report should be furnished to the medical practitioners affected by its findings. Where the Panel concludes that there was no negligence, the complainant should also receive a copy.

11. Right to Appeal: Both the medical practitioner and the complainant should have the right to challenge the Expert Panel's findings through an appeal.

12. Time-Bound Appellate Proceedings: Appropriate time limits should be prescribed for filing appeals and for their disposal by the State Level Apex Expert Committee. Where an appeal is filed within the prescribed period, the Investigating Officer should submit the final report only after the appeal has been decided.

High Court's Directions

The High Court requested the ADGP to place the proposed draft guidelines before the Kerala Government for immediate consideration and further action.

The Court also noted that the final reports in both criminal cases had been filed before the appeals challenging the Expert Panel reports were decided by the State Level Apex Expert Committee.

Consequently, it ordered that further proceedings in the corresponding calendar cases before the trial courts would remain stayed for three months.

The ADGP was directed to instruct the State Level Apex Expert Committee to decide the pending appeals within two months and make the decisions available to the High Court.

The matters were directed to be listed on September 30, 2025.

Significance of the Decision

The proposed framework seeks to ensure that investigations into medical negligence allegations are not conducted solely on the basis of expert opinions prepared without hearing the medical practitioners concerned.

It emphasises procedural fairness, specialist participation, transparent reasoning, disclosure of expert reports and an appellate mechanism for challenging adverse findings.

The decision is also relevant to Karnataka, as the High Court specifically referred to Karnataka's Standing Order No.1018 as an example of an existing procedural safeguard providing doctors with an opportunity to submit written explanations and seek personal hearings.

However, the 12-point framework in this order was a draft proposed for the Kerala Government's consideration and should not be mistaken for a set of finally notified statutory rules.

The underlying legal principle remains that criminal prosecution of medical practitioners requires proof of gross negligence or recklessness, and that medical errors or differences in professional judgment do not, by themselves, establish criminal liability.

Case Details

Case Name: Dr. Mohamed Rizwan T. v. State of Kerala and Others (Connected with Dr. L. Jayachandran v. State of Kerala and Others)

Court: High Court of Kerala at Ernakulam

Date of Decision: August 4, 2025

Case Number: Crl.M.C. Nos. 3414 and 4729 of 2025

Coram/Judge: Justice V.G. Arun